26:52
The History and Costs of Slavery in America
Hosted by Lou Perez and Phillip W. Magness .
A Free To Choose Network production.
Show Notes
Last week, Lou and Phil looked at the claim that American capitalism was built on slavery. This week, they turn to what slavery actually cost, both to the enslaved people who were denied any choice in their own work and to a Southern economy that fell far behind the North. Along the way, they look at why the American founding set much of the country on a path to abolition, and why forced labor still persists wherever the rule of law breaks down. Listen to the full episode of Happy Hour Econ with Lou and Phil.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and may contain errors.
Read Transcript
Speaker 1
Welcome back to Happy Hour Econ, where a comedian and an economist walk into a bar. I'm Lou Perez, the comedian. I just spent a few days in the gorgeous city of Savannah, Georgia. I went there with my wife to celebrate our anniversary. We had a fantastic time. For those who don't know it, Savannah is billed as the most haunted city in America, which is something they really lean into. We took a number of ghost tours.
Speaker 2
Phil Magnus, sick on.
Speaker 1
Midnight in the garden of good and evil and heard all these really creepy stories about there's a lot of dead. There's a lot of dead people in Savannah that you're apparently walking over now.
Speaker 2
You are still on dead people. Dead people, dead people, dead as far as you right to that cop car. Dead
Speaker 1
People. In addition to hearing that stuff, we also learned a little bit about the history of Savannah. And one of the things that stood out is it was founded by ⁓ Mr. James Oglethorpe. And I didn't know this, but in the early days of Savannah, there were no slaves allowed. And ⁓ well, no slaves, no lawyers, and no Catholics. You know, it just got me thinking, you know, this is one of the very surprising details about the history of slavery in in the United States. And ⁓ I thought Who better to talk about this with than ⁓ than Phil Magnus? So Phil, any any time spent in in Savannah?
Speaker 2
been down there. I didn't see any ghosts though. ⁓ they they were telling me about them. I kept looking but never saw any.
Speaker 1
Like I said, you know, they kind of lean into it to a point where I we were on like a walking tour and there were a number of different tours happening at the same time. So we would be in front of a house where this horrific thing happened and then be like, okay, we're on going on to the next one. And then we'd walk by and we we would hear another tour guide telling his tour the same story, but a few more details, you know, and it starts to be like, Hmm, is this true? Ex exactly, in order in order to sell it. So it is
Speaker 2
Is this guy embellishing it?
Speaker 1
Interesting that a whole kind of economy, you know, can develop of just talking about what happened in this place.
Speaker 2
Is interesting. Yeah. And I think the tourism economy is ⁓ you know, worth investing. Maybe there's a future episode we can do on why people go to historical places. But ⁓ you know, especially in the American South, it's interesting because you you know, s Savannah initially starts no slavery. Same could be said of Jamestown, Virginia. No slavery existed there for the first decade or so of its ⁓ establishment. And then in 1619, a slave ship arrives. And what do they do? Well, they sell their cargo of human beings to the settlers in Jamestown. And these early colonies, ⁓ you know, the legal status of slavery is actually somewhat more ambiguous than we're led to believe. ⁓ it's ⁓ it's often the case that it's like, ⁓ well, slavery arrived. And therefore, ⁓ it was off to the races to the Civil War. It's actually a much more complicated process playing out over multiple decades of trying to figure out all these different competing labor systems in the New World. Because what's going on is okay, yes, you have rich Englishmen that are obviously able to charter a ship, and some of them are these adventurer types that ⁓ Are woefully unprepared for what they're about to get into, but ⁓ mom and dad had a lot of money and gave it to them. So they charter a ship, sail across the Atlantic, and then everybody gets dysentery in smallpox and dies. ⁓ so it's like the Oregon Trail. there are others that ⁓ are ⁓ kind of on the margins of society, ⁓ maybe former criminals, some of them currently criminals. And what you do is you sign an indenture contract that says, all right, this hugely expensive. Transit across the Atlantic. ⁓ I could never afford that myself. But if you take me on your ship, ⁓ Mr. Rich Guy, I promise I'm going to work for you for the next seven years or the next 10 years or whatever my indenture contract says. And then after I finished my indenture, repaid you for the voyage back, hopefully I haven't died of dysentery and smallpox. ⁓ hopefully ⁓ our colony didn't starve. But I'll be one of the first ⁓ to have a foothold in the new world and then I can make something of myself. ⁓ so there's an early economy of laborers that come from indenture. And then there's also another ⁓ component of it is what's happening in England in the sixteen hundreds when they're constantly at civil war. And whenever some faction loses the civil war, well, what happens to the people in the captured army, the defeated army? It's like, ⁓ put them on a ship, send them to the New World and then go labor away or something. They're convicts. Essentially. ⁓ so that there's a a abundance of convicts in the ⁓ sixteen hundreds and the various British governments at the time figure a way to dispose of them is to send them to places like Georgia and ⁓ you know, put them to work. Or later it becomes Australia is settled as a prison colony, ⁓ for that same purpose. So lots of ways to get to the New World and then ⁓ it's much more so in New England, but you get ⁓ religious dissidents, ⁓ so people that were the Puritans and the pilgrims that were ⁓ cut out by the Church of England, so they seek out a new colony for themselves and it's what's sail across the ocean and we'll create our own ⁓ different religious societies.
Speaker 1
Going to the South. I'm a I'm a northerner from Queens, New York. My dad's from South America, but you know, my mom's from ⁓ from Queens. There's a whole history and culture that may have learned a little bit about it in school, but I've never lived in it, lived among the ghosts of it. And I do find it interesting, like I I've been to Charleston, another city that I absolutely loved and
Speaker 2
Lots of ghost tours.
Speaker 1
I don't think we're I don't think we had time for any ghostwors. But but we we toured a ⁓ a plantation. And yeah it's sort of this tension of it's in our past, but here I am at a place where just really unthinkable things like my the the modern mind, my modern mind can't comprehend and I'm walking amongst them and I'm having delicious food and amazing drinks, and yet there's this past that I'm also coming there to learn about and it and it's all kind of Weave together.
Speaker 2
Right, right. And you know, and it's and you study that past, and it turns out that a lot of human history, you know, at at sites that we consider famous and beautiful and celebrate for their architecture today, a lot of bad things happened there to build those sites. The Great Pyramids in Egypt. Classic example. ⁓ I guarantee you they were not paying people to lift heavy stone blocks up, and I am pretty certain that quite a few of the people involved in building those did not make it to the other side.
Speaker 1
Yeah, th they didn't have CrossFit back then when you would have a whole group of people get together to lift some stones.
Speaker 2
Right. Now slavery is much more recent in our history. I mean, we're talking a hundred and fifty, hundred and sixty years ago. It's the Civil War, ⁓ the end of slavery in America. And many of these sites that still exist, ⁓ that were built on ⁓ you know the the the bricks that were made were made there on the plantation by someone who was held against his will in slavery that's sitting there running the kiln. There are all sorts of examples of that, and that is a tangible connection to the past. You know, my whole approach to it is if you visit these historical sites, you should tell that part of the story. It's not the entirety of the story, but it's there.
Speaker 1
And ⁓ you brought up sixteen nineteen when the first slaves arrived. There were slaves going out all over the place to South America, Arabia. And people often bring that up when we discuss slavery in the United States, saying, Hey, we weren't the only ones and you know, okay, okay. ⁓ it doesn't take away from how awful it was. But I think a a question is when it comes to economics and the economic growth ⁓ over the past, you know, hundreds of years, what is it that the United States did? differently than say Brazil, which also had slaves and also had I think more slaves than than the United States had. What is it about the American experiment that left behind so many other countries who were also enslaving people?
Speaker 2
I think part of this is actually how we treated slavery, including our breakaway from slavery. ⁓ so the English part of the New World is is not too atypical compared to the other like the Spanish colonies and the Portuguese colonies. And you know, as you noted, more slaves go from Africa into Brazil, ⁓ as the Portuguese colony, and into some of the Spanish South American colonies that ever make it to the English part of the New World. ⁓ we're kind of like the the last stop on that trade. Fish is terrible trade. And it exists and it it's smuggling is still occurring up until the eve of the Civil War, even though the United States had banned the outright trade. But you know what what's different about the United States? Well, part of it is that slavery never really takes foothold in the North. There are a few small ⁓ slave economies. There's servants, ⁓ so house servants of people that are ⁓ purchased through slavery in places like Massachusetts. But there's not large scale farming like there is in, say, Virginia or the Carolinas. There's not large scale plantations like the Caribbean, which is ⁓ almost exclusively a slave economy in that era. ⁓ the fact that there were a big, geographically diverse place with a multitude of industries means that the economic power of slavery concentrates regionally, and that economic power becomes political power regionally. Adam Smith points this out. He says, Well, One of the tendencies wherever there are slave owners and they have ⁓ a significant size or presence in a colony, ⁓ what's the first thing they do? They all run for public office. They get themselves elected to the colonial assembly. And then as soon as they're in the colonial assembly, what do they do? They pass laws to subsidize and prop up slavery. And Smith, 1761, he writes this out in a lecture and he says it's it's a brilliant lecture. He says, This is why slavery is so hard to get rid of. It's not because it's a numerical majority. It clearly ⁓ like These are a very small number of elites in society. It's because the elites are all politically connected and they've figured out how to capture the tools of government and redirect it to themselves. So you've got that going on. But the United States breaks away from that and really starts right around 1776 and the American founding. The northern colonies where this political presence of slavery is not so strongly felt, they start to realize on philosophical grounds, mainly, ⁓ and sometimes religious conversions. So the Quakers are a big part of this. It's a Abolitionist-minded ⁓ religious denomination, they start to realize, you know, these principles of freedom and liberty and ⁓ you know, self-ownership and ⁓ inalienable rights, all the stuff that we're talking about and fighting this revolution over, slavery is not really consistent with that. So they start writing into their laws, look, after we break away from Britain, most of the colonies have to write new constitutions. And the very first one, it wasn't even a colony, it was kind of like the no man's land known as Vermont. In seventeen seventy seven they organize and it's claimed by New York, claimed by Massachusetts, claimed by Canada. It's kind of a backwater. No one really knows what it who it belongs to. ⁓ well that the few people that live there, they said, ⁓ well, we're gonna organize a a state, essentially. We're gonna side with these thirteen colonies in the Americas. We also want independence. So they form government in seventeen seventy seven and they write a constitution, and it's the first modern constitution in the world that banned slavery from the start. is all an extrapolation of those principles. Then you start seeing things like Massachusetts adopts a new state constitution a few years later as the newly independent United States, they need tech state constitutions. Well, they put into its preamble principles that pretty strongly imply that slavery's not allowed there anymore. And then there's a court ruling about a year or two later. That says, indeed, this new constitution, slavery is not permitted. ⁓ so they get rid of that. And then Pennsylvania, through their legislature, they vote and they decide they're going to abolish slavery. And then New York does it, then New Hampshire, and all of the northern colonies eventually become free states. Even happens on the national level in seventeen eighty-seven, they passed what's called the Northwest Ordinances, and this is the ⁓ mechanism on how to settle what is now the Midwest. It was the old Northwest of the country.
Speaker 1
Man, I'm having ⁓ flashbacks to AP American history.
Speaker 2
And there we have Ohio and Illinois and Michigan and all that part of the country. Well, ⁓ one of the mechanisms of the Northwest Ordinance, it forbids slavery from being introduced there. And that again, it's because well, slavery is inconsistent with this principle. They're like, Well, we have it in the South, it's politically entrenched there. We'll have to deal with that somewhere down the line. But at least as far as expanding the country elsewhere goes, let's just not let it take root because it's going to cause a political problem. And that's what's distinctive about the United States. So it does have a southern plantation economy that looks a lot like slavery elsewhere. It's also economically ⁓ you know kind of a throwback to feudalism in some respects. But you also have a vibrant free economy that emerges in the north and then eventually spreads to the west, ⁓ where slavery doesn't really take root. So slavery becomes geographically isolated, very powerful in that region, but eventually becomes detested outside of that region.
Speaker 1
What does that mean economically? Because ⁓ there's the economic north and then there's the economic south. What does getting rid of slavery mean for the north versus the south?
Speaker 2
Well, by the eve of the Civil War, the the North has clearly pulled ahead of the South economically in all the indicators. So you've got that. That's where the immigrants are going. It's it's production just dwarfs the South. They have industry, the South does not, except for in a few cities. So in Richmond, Virginia, there's industry, but that's about it. Overlaid on top of that is is is the question, well, yes, there are some very rich and very powerful people in the South, and a very small number of them. ⁓ and it's like, okay, well, what's their per capita wealth? A lot of it's tied up in slaves themselves. So they count the value of the slave toward their property. And if you own a thousand slaves on this giant plantation in Mississippi, you look very rich on paper. ⁓ that's clearly there. And if you did a per capita assessment of Mississippi before the Civil War, it looks like one of the richest states. But it's actually one of the poorest states. And we know this because that per capita assessment doesn't include the thousand people that are held against their will living on the plantation. It's like, wait a minute
Speaker 1
Yeah, they're only counted as property and not as
Speaker 2
And it's like, well, wait a minute, okay, if if you count the slave populations of the South, well, the per capita wealth that really alters pretty dramatically when a sizable proportion of the population ⁓ actually has nothing. So you have a ⁓ an elite that has ⁓ a whole lot all wrapped up in slave property, and then masses of the state that don't even have control of their own economic agency and they're in extreme poverty. So a true accounting of the South actually accounts for and includes the losses, the harms that are inflicted by slavery upon the people that are enslaved. I'd ask anyone that in this new history of capitalism literature or anyone that's claiming that slavery and capitalism are wetted at the hips, ⁓ are are you really defending a statistical system that denies the personhood to slaves when you're repeating some of these statistics? And y you know, they they they won't really answer those types of questions.
Speaker 1
In the last episode you listed off a number of examples of how slavery was basically state subsidized. And which makes a lot of sense when you talk about, you know, slave owners immediately kinda r running for office. Talk a little bit about what was it, fugitive slavery.
Speaker 2
Slave Act. Yeah. So the Fugitive Slave Act is passed as part of the compromise of eighteen fifty. So the slave owners of the South, especially as it's ⁓ becoming more politically ⁓ concentrated in a region, they start to notice, hey, there's this problem. Our property doesn't like being our property. It keeps running away. Fugitive slaves jump on the Underground Railroad, not a physical railroad that through safe houses, networks of safe houses. And the goal here is, you know, you get across the Ohio River and suddenly you're in a free state. And the laws of that free state, again extending back to the American founding, because remember they changed all their constitutions to abolish slavery. It's like, ⁓ if you make it to Massachusetts or you make it to Pennsylvania where slavery's not permitted, a southerner can't go up there and say, ⁓ I'm going to enforce Mississippi's laws in Philadelphia. That's a big problem. ⁓ because it it it increases the cost of maintaining the slave system in the South, because now suddenly you're a big plantation owner. ⁓ you have to hire a bunch of armed guards and basically turn your plantation into a prison camp, or else people run away. And this is also why they racialize slavery, why it evolves from this weird, ambiguous indentured servitude system in 1619 to ⁓ it's about the 1660s it starts to racialize and then this intensifies over the years. Well, they discover that wait a minute, if we define slavery as a distinct category from indentured servitude. ⁓ one, we get to inherit the ⁓ children of slaves. ⁓ so it's like a perpetual ⁓ system. Two, if we define it on racial lines and say, well, black people, because they've inherited ⁓ from the mother, ⁓ part of sequitur ventrum is the legal doctrine. They basically means your status is passed through the mother. If your mother was black and you were black, we can determine based on your skin color that you're likely a slave, that you're part of this category. legally and that makes enforcement easier. So slavery racializes as a result of the enforcement mechanism. And by the ⁓ by the eve of the Civil War, ⁓ you know, in the deep south there are very few black people that are free, ⁓ free black people that have been ⁓ and in fact states start passing laws that say to a master, if you free your slaves in your will when you die, they have to be expelled from the state, or you have to provide for them to go to Liberia or something in some of the cases. ⁓ whereas you get on the border states like Maryland that has slavery, there's actually a large free black population in the city of Baltimore that's emerged and it's economically vibrant, ⁓ even though slavery's around it. So the Fugitive Slave Act recognizes this problem because it's it's like the further north you go, if you're a slave, you start to blend into freer and freer communities. And eventually you get across the line, you're in the free state, and those laws from the South no longer apply to you. So they say, Well, what are we gonna do? Let's make the federal government the national enforcer. And now, even if you're a slave that ⁓ has escaped and breached freedom in Boston, Massachusetts, ⁓ your former owner from Georgia can file a petition and say, ⁓ nope, he's a fugitive. Send out the troops, send out the police to arrest them and bring him back home to me. And there are several high-profile incidents of this that happened in the eighteen fifties. One of them is called the ⁓ the Burns riot in Boston. Where they kind of make this ⁓ cause ⁓ into like a a celebrity illustration of the horrors of the Fugitive Slave Act. Burns is the escaped slave, he reaches freedom in Boston, then his owner sa ⁓ makes a claim under the Fugitive Slave Act against him. And as a show of force, even though it's just this one guy, so all the abolitionists, of course, they rally around him and try to protect him from being arrested. Federal agents arrest him and they throw him in the federal courthouse. The abolitionists are furious. And there's an actual plot to spring them from the jail. Really sophisticated plot. It almost worked ⁓ until ⁓ they think one of the prison guards ⁓ accidentally pulled the trigger of his ⁓ his gun and then everyone fled because it's like, ⁓ there's there's actual death and danger going on here. But ⁓ because of the Burns riots, the attempt to spring him from the the jail, the federal government said under our obligation of the Fugitive Slave Act, we are now going to deploy thousands of Of US Marines to the streets of Boston to escort this guy back to his ship and sail back to the South. And they end up spending like an ungodly amount of the federal budget on just removing one slave to the South. And you're like, why does this even make sense? Well, it makes sense is a show of force. So by spending tens of thousands of dollars and deploying troops, ⁓ you know, ⁓ you know, probably actually millions of dollars in today's money to be adjust for inflation. ⁓ deploying troops, a federal escort, navy vessels, you name it, to get one person back to the South, we're showing that we're serious and we will enforce slavery in the North, even if your own state laws don't recognize this. And that itself becomes one of the major emphasises for why the Civil War happened.
Speaker 1
This is before a federal income tax, right? I'm just anachronistically just thinking about it from you know in Boston looking at this happen and I'm like, What are my tax dollars going towards? Just so some rich slave owner can, you know, get his quote unquote property back? How were those fees being paid?
Speaker 2
Right. So tariffs and excises were the main revenues of the US government at the time. And, you know, they're collected in in various ways nationally. You know, there's some famous examples in the in the Mexican War, Henry David Thoreau, the ⁓ the poet and novelist. He writes this famous essay on civil disobedience, and it's all about he views it as unjust that he's being made to pay the taxes to fight this war, one of the goals of which is to expand the territory that slavery exists in. So tax protests become very heavily wrapped up. in the anti-slavery causes. Again, this is why the notion that the like slavery and capitalism are hand in hand. No, it's it's the radical libertarian tax protesters are also the radical libertarian abolitionists in that era. And they are viewing any government involvement in slavery as like you know, this is a distortion of free markets. ⁓ this is a distortion economically as well as a moral abomination. So they justify their tax protests on the grounds that the ⁓ the federal government has ⁓ perpetuated a ⁓ a wrong in slavery.
Speaker 1
I think it's pretty clear that slavery was an economic handicap for the South. And just to give like an example, when I was in Savannah, I went to ⁓ the Savannah College of Art and Design and they had a little presentation, a very short documentary about Ellen and William Kraft, which was actually I I read the book that William Kraft wrote about him and his wife, and both of them were enslaved in the South, and they escaped to Philadelphia. And the way that they escaped was Ellen was very light skinned. Yeah. Exactly. She could pass f for white and she dressed up like a white man and they played the role as if her husband was, you know, her enslaved attendee. And finally they they get to Philadelphia and William opens up a carpentry business. Yeah. Then at some point they start feeling the heat again around the corner. And it's like, ⁓ now we gotta get out of here. So then they they go to to England and they have a life in England and then eventually they wanna come back to the States. And you just look at slavery is awful and look how unproductive this is.
Speaker 2
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Some of the these stories of ⁓ the fugitive slaves, the people that escaped to freedom, they are some of the most innovative entrepreneurial people in American history. And you see this over and over again. People that were like held in chains to menial tasks on a farm, they reach Boston or Philadelphia and they become like fabulously successful entrepreneurs out of nothing. Well, that's the ⁓ illustration of the opportunity cost of slavery. It denies human agency to, you know, choose your own career. And if your your only lot in life is to do this repetitive task on a cotton field, you're denied the opportunity to innovate. And if you escape that, you're thrown in by necessity into a situation where you have to discover for economic reasons as well as social reasons, survival. And that that means you innovate and you discover. ⁓ you know, how to make something of yourself. And it's the it's a real world demonstration. Hey, slavery is an economic tax first and foremost upon the enslaved people themselves.
Speaker 1
We are now in the year twenty twenty six and unfortunately slavery is a real thing around the world. Yeah. Are we seeing kind of similar things ⁓ as far as, you know, countries where there is slavery, as far as, you know, economic stymieing, ⁓ you know, for not to mention the outright human rights abuses. Yeah.
Speaker 2
Well, ⁓ and you know, a a lot of countries that this type of systems exist in still, that they're very reluctant to call it slavery because it has a stigma. And in fact, you know, throughout most of the nineteenth century, the British Empire kind of ⁓ appoints itself to stamp out slavery on the high seas and they send its navy to raid the slave colonies. Of ⁓ of other ⁓ countries and other the slave trading kingdoms of Africa in particular. So there is an effort to like legally stamp out exercises of slavery, but ⁓ you know, conditional exercises of slavery. Well, what is North Korea today? It's basically a massive slave state run by a communist dictator. And what do slave states do, whether it's like the Fugitive Slave Act or trying to force people back onto the plantation? Well, what's North Korea? They have a giant wall around themselves. The the number one thing that they try to do is to make sure nobody gets out. Or if they get out, they're they're highly supervised to go work in the Chinese factory and then come back. And if you fall out of line, you know, bad things happen to you. ⁓ so it's basically a state operated ⁓ slave plantation, essentially like that. And then you have other areas where the rule of law is weak to non existent. So failed states in particular in in Africa have had this problem that there is still basically de facto slavery occurring. places without a functional government, you look at somewhere like Somalia, ⁓ you have warlords that are essentially engaged in slave trade, in addition to all the other horrible things that they're doing. ⁓ so it's like the further you move away from a functional system of rule of law, the further you move away from a functional capitalist economy, the more likely these types of institutions tend to emerge. ⁓ and you know I don't think that's by accident. you look back historically The example in the United States, ⁓ the southern states are the least capitalistic. If you use ⁓ any coherent definition rooted in, you know, private property, free labor, rule of law. Well, where where is that the weakest? It's actually in the plantation stakes.
Speaker 1
We hope you enjoyed this episode of Happy Hour Econ. We'll see you next week.
Listen & Watch
Share This Episode
Pull up a stool with Lou and Phil
Next
Round's
On Us
New Episodes, Straight to Your Inbox. No Cover Charge.
No spam, just good economics served with a side of laughs. Unsubscribe anytime.