Back to Episodes
Artwork for Majoring in Debt

28:59

Majoring in Debt

Hosted by Lou Perez and Phillip W. Magness .

A Free To Choose Network production.

Show Notes

Ah, college. A time for late-night study sessions, questionable roommates, and, of course, finding yourself. But what happens when the bill for all that soul-searching comes due? With new rules set to limit federal loans for degrees that don’t earn enough, Lou and Phil take a hard look at the economics of higher ed: who’s paying the bill, who’s cashing in, and whether a diploma is worth the price. Class is in session at the bar on this week’s Happy Hour Econ. No tuition required.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and may contain errors.

Read Transcript

Speaker 1

Welcome back to Happy Hour Econ, where a comedian and an economist walk into a bar. I'm Lou Perez, the comedian.

Speaker 2

I'm Phil Magnus, the economist.

Speaker 1

Trump moves to cut off student loans for tons of degrees. The New Republic writes: If your degree doesn't make enough money, you won't be able to get a student loan. So is this a moment of joy for you out there? Is it a moment of pain? Because I've been seeing Both joy and pain and a lot of anger on social media feeds. But first off, what is Trump and the new rule doing exactly? Phil.

Speaker 2

So I I'm mostly joyful about this one, although, you know, I'm kind of in the wait and see phase of how it's actually implemented and executed. The idea here is that our higher education sector industry has been highly distorted by the fact that government subsidizes students to participate in it, to take out loans at deeply discounted rates and sometimes with the promise that maybe the government will step in and bail them out at a future point. to go get a degree in whatever, to go to college and discover yourself. And, you know, all the all the usual marketing gimmicks that they say to draw people into higher ed. And what this has done over the years is it's created an overproduction of degrees in things that really don't have much of an employment market in them. you know, we have joked in some previous episodes about the puppetry degree program. You want to get a major in puppetry, you can apparently do that. But I don't think that the employment market's all that great. But there there are also all these other fields that have popped up, especially in the humanities, that are really just kind of like political activism. you know, it's the gender studies and critical pedagogy and even some of the more traditional fields like sociology and English literature and poetry and stuff, have moved in a very heavily activist direction. And as a result. People will go there and they'll spend four or five, six years getting a degree in that. And then they'll go back and they'll take up more loans and get a master's degree or a PhD in that. And at the end, there's really not much of an employment market for it other than to be a college professor. Well, it turns out the college professor market for poetry PhDs is. vastly oversaturated. There are far too many people with poetry PhDs and not any jobs in it. So you get like these ads that are put out for hiring a new poetry professor and a hundred or two hundred people will apply for it and for one single job. And what this basically means is that you got the saturated market of job seekers with degrees that really don't have much of an employment market, that all went up through the student loan system over the past several decades. And Y y you know, now it's kinda like the the government itself by stepping in there in the first place is what distorted that market. And Trump s is saying something to the effect of, Well, maybe we ought to curtail or restrict throwing money into incentivizing people to get degrees that really don't have a a a very viable employment sector.

Speaker 1

And correct me if I'm wrong, but I remember from a couple of years ago, you had posted on X, or maybe it was Twitter at the time, just talking about the glut of historians, of PhDs in in history. And, you know, you're kind of looking at your own people and saying, hey guys, you're looking around like there's a lot of us.

Speaker 2

and I I've studied this. Actually, my book with Jason Brennan, Cracks in the Ivory Tower. We have a whole segment of a chapter on the PhD over production glut. And there's also a master's degree over production glut. There's also an undergrad degree glut. my colleague at the Independent Institute, Richard Vedder, also addresses this in his provocatively titled book, Let Colleges Fail. part of it is the fact that the higher ed system has basically been set up to churn out credentials for people without any consideration of if there's a market for that credential to begin with. And you see this in data, like advanced degrees in accounting are in extremely high demand because the world needs a lot of accountants. same thing with engineers. I guess petrochemical engineering might be like one of the highest paid fields out there. There is not a a a a glut of job seekers. And in fact, you can command a a a very strong salary if you have even an undergraduate degree in a lot of these fields and engineering, business, accounting. Economics is another one of them, on that that it does have an academic but also a private sector component to it. And yet you move into some of these softer degrees like anthropology, sociology, history, or gender studies and some of these more activist fields, we have far too many people have obtained advanced degrees in them relative to a very limited workforce that's almost entirely we can go teach college, or the other thing they've they've ended up doing is they go into higher education administration. So you can be the dean of parking lots. These types of jobs explode in number on campus. we show this with the data. And they tend to be filled with people that have degrees in fields that just really don't have a very robust post-graduation job market. And you layer on top of that the fact that people are taking out student loans for it. Well, there's a reason behind this. It was an already distorted market. We go back to the financial crisis in 2008. One of the aftermath responses to that. And I I think some of it started under George W. Bush, but Obama came in in two thousand nine, was one of the big instigators of this. well, they faced an employment market strain in general because we were in a recession. Unemployment was high. well, one of their strategies to mitigate that was you defer young people's entry into the job market. And one way to do that is you pay them to go get more credentials, you pay them to go back to school. So they really loosened up the student loan availability, they threw a bunch of money into it. federal government took a more centralized presence in a student loan policy and basically absorbed a lot of that onto itself. so you had this massive public sector incentivization of people to get degrees in anything and everything to keep them out of the job market while the economy recovered. otherwise it would strain the unemployment rate. You know, that's the the short version of the story. But it just produced a whole bunch of people seeking credentials without any clear like postgraduation plan. For this or a clear job market, do it. And that created a constituency over the next decade that now wants their student loans forgiven.

Speaker 1

Look, I'm one of those humanities people. the humanities I went to NYU where I was basically an English major. I say basically because I I went to Gallatin. If there are any Gallatin heads out there, you know that we get to basically pick our own major or our concentration, if you will. I'm very happy for the most part with the education that I got. And but like you said before, I I kind of look back and I was like, man, how much of it was about that like finding yourself thing? I mean I was Finding myself as a 18 to 22-year-old in New York City, you know, having a really good time. And even looking at kind of how pop culture represents college, it's very rare that you'll see a movie about college that isn't about partying or hooking up or finding yourself. The closest you'll get is something like a Goodwill hunting that, you know, kind of goes into like mathematics, but yet Will is a janitor who's he's not even enrolled.

Speaker 2

He's he's not even a traditional student, is he?

Speaker 1

The genius. I I went the other round, I I continued and went and got my my MFA at City College. And one of the best things that happened to me was I had applied to Columbia University for an MFA and I got rejected. And it's one of the best things that happened because the amount of money I would have had to spend to attend Columbia basically

Speaker 2

Yeah.

Speaker 1

getting the same the same education. And you know, something to make clear, you know, for people who were really Worried about this, or you know, people who whatever Trump touches, you're not gonna like. He's not banning these majors. You know, there there was sort of this thread going around, like he's getting rid of the arts, et cetera. He's he's not banning them. You could still take these courses, you just have to find a different way to pay for them.

Speaker 2

Yeah, you actually have to pay for what you are consuming. I guess because quite a few of these courses, even though they're presented as like this human capital development model, what they really are are they consumption goods for people who like painting or puppetry or arts. they think, well, I'm going to go spend five, six, seven years pursuing a succession of degrees in this because I like doing it. I'm gonna spend half a decade discovering myself. Well, that's great and all if you want to do that, but somebody has to pay the bill. And there's a misalignment of incentives here because you know, if if you imagine you're a college administrator and the government is saying, we're going to subsidize loans for all these people to come to your university and spend the next five, six, seven years discovering themselves. What are you going to say as a college administrator? Please send them my way. And in fact, I hope they discover themselves five or six times over in the course of their stay here. Cause every time they switch majors, that means they have to take more classes. And every new class they have to take, they have to pay for that. But they aren't paying for it. It's actually the government subsidized loan that is paying for it. And you know, for a college administrator, this is like, this is free money to me. this is how I fund my bloated English department to continue hiring faculty, even though no one really wants to get an English degree other than those that are subsidized to be.

Speaker 1

And looking at where we are now compared to where I was in college, what man, like twenty years ago, all of the options you have now to basically take courses for free online and lectures and all of this stuff, there's nothing stopping, say, a licensed electrician from also studying Shakespeare in his free time. There is no gate keeping out people who have regular jobs from doing things like that. I I was recently reading about Robert Mull, who passed Passed away a couple of years ago. He was a great comedic actor. And I learned about all these other things about him, all these other talents that he had that I had no idea. He was a painter. He was a musician. He did all these things. He was, you know, one man who had a lot of hobbies and was very good at them and was able to do that. I know guys who are, you know, blue-collar workers who are in bands.

Speaker 2

Exactly.

Speaker 1

There really, th this idea that somehow you're being kept out from the humanities or kept out from the arts because you have to go a different a different route is just just silly.

Speaker 2

It it it is. And you know, we look at the higher ed landscape. if you want to learn Shakespeare, and so say you're an eighteen to twenty-two year old, you're in this territory of going to college and you're really into Shakespeare. My advice to you would be sign up for the Shakespeare class at your local community college. It'll maybe cost a couple hundred bucks, and you'll probably get a better introduction to Shakespeare. Than the critical theory Marxist version of it taught at Yale and Princeton and these elite institutions, where it's Shakespeare, but Shakespeare through a lens of income inequality or climate change, that sort of nonsense that pervades at the top of the higher ed profession tends to be much more politicized and much more detached from the actual sh subject matter. And this is one of the things that a lot of elite institutions have found. they offer the Shakespeare class, but no one really wants to take them because it's just being harped at over and over by a political activist rather than learning the the the material of particular plays. So what do they do? Then they start requiring them to get your general education credit before you can graduate and go on to your major. so there's a whole shell game that's played at the top of the discipline, whereas you can get more or less the same content, probably taught. Better in the sense that it's more grounded in the material if you go to your community college for a tiny fraction of the price.

Speaker 1

So what's going to happen to these professions that are no longer being effectively subsidized by the government? You know, is the government picking winners here? I

Speaker 2

I think they already picked the winners in previous decades when they said they were going to subsidize everything. So I see this as more of a coming back down to earth, a correction. yeah. So if you look from about the nineteen nineties to the present, that's when you start getting the degree overproduction, not just undergraduate, but advanced degrees, master's degrees, PhDs, MFAs, anything with multiple letters after it, that is really being fueled by the student loan infusion. That was the original distortion. What we're seeing now, you know, assuming this is executed in a a somewhat sane way, and again, that's a big if because it's the government implementing the program. What it does is it actually returns a semblance of the market for these types of degrees into higher education. It's no longer people are pursuing a degree because we've made it. very inexpensive to get loans to pursue that degree, regardless of the job market for it. They're pursuing that degree for something where they have skin in the game. They actually have to pay for it themselves and either take on the risk and loan that's associated with that degree, or they choose to have a different career in a different area. And it doesn't mean that they can have to stop all painting on the side or or cease playing music or cease being part of a band. it just means that there's no longer a public sector subsidy that's already distorting that market.

Speaker 1

And from that same article from the New Republic, quote, the education department intends to use IRS data to determine students' salaries four years after they graduate and compare them to those people of similar in age. Wait, those of people similar in age. Wow, talk about finding a typo in

Speaker 2

In the in the bureaucratic code.

Speaker 1

So they're basically gonna be comparing those people to those who just have high school diplomas. If they're below that baseline, that degree will be ineligible for loans. And this seems like it just makes things really complicated. Like is that is that even a good metric to determine? I I'm looking at myself and I graduated, I was I was twenty two and I was thinking, how long did it take me post graduation to find a job where I was making like a a solid, you know, income? And I think probably like in my thirties when when I started making, you know, was money that you'd look at and be like, okay. That's a professional there. Yeah.

Speaker 2

You're discovering yourself all before that.

Speaker 1

I spent way too much time discovering myself and now I'm a midlife crisis discovering myself.

Speaker 2

Yeah, well, yeah, and I I think this is where the bureaucracy comes into it. Cause they're saying, yes, we'll look at IRS data. This is the classic government answer when someone up above said, Yeah, make this happen. Go implement this thing. Well, they're going to pull out their papers. Well, how do we do that? IRS data. That's appealing to me. The reality is we have all sorts of statistics and measurements. A lot of it's gathered by the private sector that gives like the median. salary expectation for a career in X, Y, or Z. that's everything from median salary to auto mechanic to median salary to a high-end corporate accountant to a lawyer to puppetry major. Data exists on all sorts of things like this. they're probably saying go to the IRS data because they are the government and that's the one that that's the safe route for them, even though it may be the most bureaucratic. And it does kind of have a a weird feedback loop into it. So this is again why I caveat my general favor for discouraging student loans in these degrees with the fact that you know it may be implemented in a typical bureaucratic hapless way. well yeah, there's your answer. Going to the IRS data may not be the the clearest route to execute on this.

Speaker 1

And I would imagine too it could depend on which school people go to, right? I you know, if you go to I guess one of the Ivy League schools, there's a possibility that, you know, you get hired right out of college to, you know, be an editor or or something like that and you're making man, how much do editors make? I got I got looking for a job.

Speaker 2

I mean we should go on to like one of these pay scale websites and there's probably a regional date on that. Yeah. Well there's a there's another paradox of it. the most expensive schools tend to be these elite Ivy League. you know, you're paying over a hundred thousand dollars a year to get your fancy degree from Yale or Princeton or one of these exclusive institutions, versus you may be paying like ten or fifteen thousand dollars a year if you're going to the local state public community college or third tier university. Well, yes, part that comes with the Ivy League has a hiring premium attached to it. But that hiring premium also comes with, you know, if you have a PhD in history from Yale, you have a leg up on the history job market. That's just a very small oversaturated job market. so even people with PhDs from the top institution aren't always guaranteed a tenure track job because there's just so few of them out there. you have too many seekers. Aggregated up over years and years and years of this for a very small number of jobs. you've already got a glut in that that sector, and it's gonna be very top-heavy because that's just the nature of academia. what I see in that territory is the process of student loan subsidies, the process of throwing money over the IV walls in general has created a very unequal, skewed, disproportionate job market in those sectors that's elite, that's very, very small. And it's glutted with too many seekers of positions. But that's all a product of decades of distortion from the government. Disentangling that is a very tricky process. Insofar as this does try to go somewhat in that direction, I think the disentangling is good. It's just again, the question is how are they going to be able to execute?

Speaker 1

When I was at city college getting my my MFA, again, I don't know who that's impressing, but I was an adjunct for a professor who ran a lecture, I think it was like a weekly lecture, and then we would break off into small classes that, you know, the adjuncts would would run. And this guy was one of the worst professors ever. And I'm not talking like y you hear some complaints like, this professor is, you know, from a different country and his accent is really thick. No, no, it wasn't it wasn't that. It was he was so unprofessional. He would often show up, I'm not kidding, forty five minutes late. He he would

Speaker 2

And always a story that implausible thing of why no

Speaker 1

No, no, he didn't even do that. You he didn't even try to come up with an excuse. He would just show up and then this was like a a course for for freshmen, a humanities course, great li I think it was great works of literature. And he wouldn't even lecture. He would he would throw it out to the lecture hall. Anybody have any questions about what you read? And having been someone who I had really great professors as as as undergrad. I was like, this is this is disgusting. Like this is really this is really beyond the pale.

Speaker 2

Guy is phoning it in, very clearly not taking his job seriously.

Speaker 1

And protected. And protected. And protected. He had tenure. it turns out later I believe he I believe he died of a brain tumor. which I guess explains some of it. But if we're if we're getting to that point, I mean it's time to time Yeah.

Speaker 2

Yeah.

Speaker 1

Yeah, for sure. So, you know, if we were looking for a metric to decide what gets funding, what doesn't. I know you and I are probably in the camp of none of it gets but if we were looking at a metric, what would be, you know, something that would be more easier to to actually do?

Speaker 2

you know, I'd say look at hiring salary, the starting salary for recent graduates in that program. And there there's quite a bit of data on that out there. You can get rank ordered by degree from the least paying salary to the highest paying salary. And I th I think I looked up this once and even though it's a very niche program, but like the lowest paying major that one could get in the United States was like blacksmithing. that meant you can go work at the Renaissance Festival, I guess, which or or the the historical village and make horseshoes or something. but there somewhere, some place offered a degree in blacksmithing and and it did not even come close to yielding an average starting salary that would have repaid the degree. And then on the other end, it was stuff like the petroleum engineers that we've discussed. so looking at something like that, it might be a point where you can draw the dividing line. And you know, everything above this dividing line has eligibility if we're going to offer loans, and you know, I'm even skeptical of that, public sector at least. Yes, the private sector should be able to offer loans within reason because they are doing risk assessments. This is something that if the entire college loan sector was strictly private and you were looking to take out a loan to go to Brown University for the next eight years to get a PhD in social justice activism and you went and applied for a loan and you had to fill out a form that said that, do you think they'd give you the loan? I don't know.

Speaker 1

I mean from our from our previous episodes we you know we talked about how people are making a good living. You know, some people are making a pretty good living. In particular the anti-capitalists are making a really good

Speaker 2

That's yeah, yeah. Well, yeah, you know, like and if functional information existed, private sector would process it, at least in market decisions. When you bureaucratize it and say there's like this one size fits all rule for everybody who applies for a loan, whether you are seeking a productive degree or you're basically discovering yourself for the next several years, you get the same loan and the same rate, there's actually no market feedback mechanism anymore. to the lender, which is why the government steps in and then you get things like w what Joe Biden tried to do, which is, Well, let's forgive everybody's loan. So the moral hazard kicks

Speaker 1

And on that, how will we demand cancel student loan debt if that debt no longer exists? What what new slogan can we possibly use if the problem is taken care of itself?

Speaker 2

Yeah, so how do we buy off votes and how do we throw money into the university system? Hence we see like here's the political incentive of why, yeah, you know, the the politicians will sell to the public. We want to invest in student loans because we are investing in our future, our next generation. Think of all the benefits to society of everyone being educated in Shakespeare and then also knowing scientific discoveries that come out of the that's how they pitch to the public to subsidize these things. And so far the public's generally been willing to go along with it, but they've started to scrutinize higher ed and they're realizing what I think is becoming pretty increasingly obvious the return to the public for this investment in subsidizing student loans is not what we signed up for. At best, it's a very fickle return that has a lot of people discovering themselves but not really getting productive degrees out of it. And at worst, it's like educating people in Marxist activism.

Speaker 1

And something that I've seen a lot are people who are kind of bragging about having paid off their loans and you know, that's that's great. And using that as a way of saying, hey, I paid off my loans, you know what? I'm all for canceling other people's student loans. But what I always wondered is is if that's the case, if your idea is that you want to cancel student loans, then the understanding should be There are no more student loans after this, right? Or your student loans are no longer protected by the government because you can't continue this cycle of insanity.

Speaker 2

Exactly. Exact and and I think unfortunately, you know, this is the they're kind of showing their hand here when they make those types of arguments because none of them want to terminate or end the student loan program. They're like, this is just a one time forgiveness until 15 years from now we're back at the exact same thing. You know, it's it's the foot in the door strategy to getting more subsidies for higher education. And again, you know who loves this? The tenured professors. The college administrators, the people that are running the higher ed racket of churning out useless degrees and taking in subsidized loan money from students. He, you know, you know, frankly, I I think a lot of this is kind of unethical. People that are eighteen, nineteen, twenty years old are in a more precarious economic position in their life than a fifty-five year old tenured professor who phones it in like the guy that you had that showed up forty-five minutes late for class. He's the one that benefits from the fact that we're throwing money into higher ed and the debt gets saddled onto a nineteen or twenty year old who has to take his classes to get their degree at a completely inflated, ostentatious price that doesn't seem to have any semblance in the market. I look at that and I'm like, you know, this is kind of an unethical generational transfer. And yet the professor, their solution to that is say, well, we'll fix the unethical aspect of it, the fact that we basically scammed people into a useless degree and delivered a very poor quality product in the classroom to them, by saying, well, we'll just get the government to bail them out a couple of years from now and we'll shirk any responsibility to that. So there's a lot of ethical problems that emerge from this type of behavior. And yet it's i it's it's all about like kicking the can down the road in higher ed.

Speaker 1

Well yeah, I do wonder are colleges kind of off the hook because you know, shouldn't they be held accountable? It's like, hey, you're the one who charged me all this.

Speaker 2

Yeah. Well, this is this is Adam Smith made this point in The Wealth of Nations. Seventeen seventy-six, two hundred and fifty years ago, he pointed out, you know, he did he did he was a college professor, so he did the tour of the British and Scottish university systems. And he noticed he was down at Oxford that was supposedly this elite ancient university, which it is. but he got down there and he noticed that a lot of his colleagues were professors like that one you described that were phoning it in and reading decades old notes and didn't really care. And he's sitting there thinking about it, he's going, wait a minute. problem here is the way that they have their tuition system set up. The professor gets paid no matter what. And then there's no price mechanism where the students can signal back to the professor that, hey, this is a good class, this is a bad class. And Smith said, actually there's some of the Scottish universities had a different system where it was kind of almost like a tipping system, a tuition tipping system where the better professors got paid more and the students could make had some say in that decision. to give them a little bonus if they gave good lectures and delivered on what they were doing. And and Smith basically says, you know, the tipping system, because it ties the financial interest of the student to the classroom and to what's being provided, yields a better product than this supposed elite ancient university of Oxford where everyone gets paid no matter what they do. And I think the student loan system that's emerged is much more like what Smith saw in Oxford. So unfortunately we've gone down that track. rather than towards some sort of market mechanism guiding higher education. that's that's a lot of where we are today.

Speaker 1

People have been really vocal about the problem with student loan debt and students graduates being just buried, you know, up to their neck in it and a lot of people who haven't even graduated. And I think it was probably most vocal during the the Biden administration. But, you know, with that it's sort of like for those who do want to cancel student loan, there's gotta be a cutoff point because it's sort of like if If you every time you open Facebook and TikTok and X and Snapchat and you know all of these devices and people are just talking about how bad student loan debt is, and then you still go out and take out this ungodly amount of money in a loan rather than going to a much, you know, cheaper alternative, at some point I gotta be like, Hey buyer, beware. you you knew exactly what you were getting into. Yeah.

Speaker 2

I think that's exactly it. I mean, sending the market signal back is the way to fix the larger problem. The more that we take it out of the hands of the consumers of education, the students, the providers of education, the professors and the university system, and move it into this third party in the government, you distort and and cloud and suppress the signals, that's when you get what I would call academic malinvestment. in puppetry degrees or all these other things that don't really have a career attached to.

Speaker 1

Well, we hope you've enjoyed this free education from Happy Hour Econ. We hope you've found yourself many times throughout this episode. Find us again and find yourself again next week for an all-new episode of Happy Hour Econ.

Share This Episode

Pull up a stool with Lou and Phil

Next
Round's
On Us

New Episodes, Straight to Your Inbox. No Cover Charge.

Sign up to get a quick note each week when a new round (episode) is ready to pour.

No spam, just good economics served with a side of laughs. Unsubscribe anytime.

Happy Hour Econ

Now Playing

Majoring in Debt