31:03
Slavery, Capitalism, and the Historical Record
Hosted by Lou Perez and Phillip W. Magness .
A Free To Choose Network production.
Show Notes
A recent CNN debate put a pointed question before a national audience. Is capitalism bound up with racism and slavery? Slavery predates writing, and it predates capitalism by thousands of years, yet a growing body of scholarship argues that the modern American economy rests on the forced labor of enslaved people. In this week's Happy Hour Econ, Lou and Phil test those claims against the historical record and revisit what the defenders of slavery themselves had to say about free markets.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and may contain errors.
Read Transcript
Speaker 1
Welcome back to Happy Hour Econ, where a comedian and an economist walk into a bar. I'm Lou Perez, the comedian. And ⁓ I don't know if you guys caught this, but a really interesting discussion happened on CNN. Jamel Hill, who's a writer for The Atlantic, she was arguing that capitalism is bound up in white supremacy. And on that panel was Camille Foster of the Fifth Column Podcast, and he had this to say.
Speaker 2
I'm Phil Magnus, the economist. Slavery is older than writing. It predates capitalism. The notion that white supremacy are bound up with capitalism in an intrinsic and fundamental way is so absurd and laughable that it barely needs to be defended. What do you mean it barely needs to be defended? It barely needs to be defended. You actually connection is. How are these two things the same? So here's I'm talking about private property, the right exchange and sell it with whoever you like. What does it have to do with white supremacy?
Speaker 1
And a number of people were sharing this, retweeting it, saying, Camille, you destroyed, you absolutely killed. But on X, you had ⁓ commenters like Mark Lamont Hill who responded, quote, This gentleman didn't obliterate Jamel at all. He just confidently said a bunch of things that weren't true. He would benefit from reading about racial capitalism as the beginning to the developing an answer to his question. So, first off, racial capitalism. What's going on with that? Because in another post, Lamont Hill wrote that capitalism is absolutely rooted and dependent upon processes of racialization. These are very academic words, and it just makes me wonder that, you know, if capitalism is racist and or built on white supremacy, isn't racial capitalism kinda redundant? Yeah.
Speaker 2
It's a little bit circular in the argument here. ⁓ and I think you're absolutely right in pointing out these are academic jargon terms, ⁓ racial capitalism, ⁓ you know, the hierarchies referring to race, all this sort of thing. ⁓ but they're proprietary jargon that comes from a very narrow strain of far left academic literature, and that literature refers to itself as the racial capitalism literature. ⁓ so what is that? Well, racial capitalism is a term that's coined by ⁓ this political scientist by the name of Cedric Robinson in the early 1980s. And I guess the best way to think of him, ⁓ for audiences that are not ⁓ familiar with obscure academic debates, ⁓ he's something of a parallel to the critical race theory movement, although he's not directly a part of that. So we've heard a lot about CRT recently. ⁓ there's a Parallel track that emerges under Cedric Robinson, and it refers to itself as black Marxism. And the idea here is to take Marxist concepts, but to purge them of their Eurocentrism and reorient them around racial identity rather than class identity being the ⁓ the the mechanism of the dividing line of society, the ⁓ exploitation. versus the exploiters, which was the core of the Marx system. But Marx, again, he did that on class. Well Cedric Robinson says, you know, Marx was a bit too Eurocentric. ⁓ we actually need to look out around the world and and see ⁓ you know, do these concepts apply in other racial senses? So he's preserving the Marxist core architecture, but he's deviating from Marx on the unit of analysis. And what he basically comes up with is this claim that capitalism exists to reinforce racial hierarchies. Power dynamics between ⁓ the majority race, ⁓ i.e. white people in the United States, and the minority race, ⁓ black people are bound up in economic relationships that are intended to extract from the black people and give to the white people. ⁓ that that's essentially what it comes down to. It's a mechanism of exploitation, but on racial grounds. And this kind of hovers in the fringes and ether of academic debate for several decades. But then when we have the Great Awokening, ⁓ you know, the period in the early twenty tens when academia shifts very hard to the left, suddenly Cedric Robinson, who's kind of faded into the ⁓ the background in academic debate since the early nineteen eighties, becomes one of the stars that they seize onto and elevate as an explanation for supposedly everything.
Speaker 1
Capitalism is so wild because you can make a great living being a black anti-capitalist. And which I just find so interesting. It's sort of you have this industry where people are going on CNN, selling books, giving lectures, your professors at college, and it's by pushing this beyond. Perhaps that's anecdotal, perhaps that's a way of saying, like, ⁓ well, some people are doing good within this. But I I think overall, capitalism is doing
Speaker 2
Right. This narrative.
Speaker 1
pretty well for a lot of people, a lot of people who happen to be people of color.
Speaker 2
Well, ⁓ know, I I point one of the examples of a popularizer of this ⁓ black Marxism narrative, the anti-capitalism ⁓ literature is Nicole Hannah Jones, ⁓ the creator of the sixteen nineteen project. And not only did she become fabulously wealthy from the sixteen nineteen project, she reportedly charges forty thousand dollars for a one hour lecture, and she does dozens of these around the country every year. ⁓ so she's doing quite well promoting a grievance narrative that's basically attacking capitalism. But there's one other dimension I think that ⁓ warrants bringing out, and that is the academic literature behind this. Although Cedric Robinson, you know, he styles himself as ⁓ the continuation of this black radical tradition, which goes back to the early 20th century. It's W.E.B. Du Bois ⁓ the civil rights leader who later becomes a Marxist and then a Stalinist at the end of his life. ⁓ so that's a really interesting turn. ⁓ yes, that background is there, but the modern promoters of this racial capitalism narrative have c kind of morphed it into a broader academic literature that came onto the scene in the early 2010s. And this is what Mark Lamont Hill is referring to. This is what the ⁓ the debate on CNN was really about, and that is the relationship between slavery and capitalism. And they draw almost entirely on a very narrow genre of academic literature that refers to itself as the new history of capitalism school. And they popped onto the scene again in the early 2010s. And I've basically been at war with these people ever since then. It's a group of historians, mostly at Ivy League Institution. And the other irony about them, they're all white males. It's Sven Beckert, Ed Baptist, Seth Rockman, ⁓ these are ⁓ historians at Cornell and Brown University and Harvard and places like that, they're all white males that come from a very far left wing ideological perspective. And their narrative is that because ⁓ slavery produced things that sold on a market, which it very obviously did, produced cotton for export, it produced tobacco and ⁓ indigo and rice and sugar, because it exchanged on a market, it was therefore at its core capitalistic, and then they jumped from that to To the claim that ⁓ slavery is an important part of the early American economy. ⁓ therefore, American capitalism and American industrialization and everything that's happened since slavery is therefore built on the backs of plantation labor and exploitation. ⁓ so this is all building up toward a narrative that our modern economy today, our wealth today, is supposedly the result of exploiting slaves 150 plus years ago. and then they jump from that, well. Therefore, capitalism today is tainted by the brutality of slavery. Therefore, we need to socialize the economy or we need massive multitrillion dollar reparations payments or all these political causes that are relevant to the present day, they're trying to use the past as a mechanism and an argument ⁓ to to bring it to the forefront. What
Speaker 1
The idea of socializing the economy, I'm just imagining if you were to make that argument back during the days of slavery, basically what you'd be saying is we want the state to be in charge of slavery. Right. But now today it's because the same people who find white supremacy, etc., in capitalism also see that within all three branches of government. So they want the same kind of ⁓ systemic oppressor to be then in control of more. I I feel like maybe I'm doing too much academic speak ⁓ now, but I'm just trying I'm just trying to get this idea of you want put centralized control into the hands of people who you believe are oppressing you.
Speaker 2
Yeah, i I I think at its core, ⁓ you know, and this and this is the complexity of it. We dress these ⁓ these ⁓ concepts up in academic terms and we talk about them as if they're complex ideas, but at the core of the new history of capitalism is a really facile, superficial, fact deprived, unrigorous reading of history. ⁓ I mean i it's it's actually a scandal. It's it's a shock that these people are at Harvard and Princeton and Yale as the supposed leading lights of the history profession. I mean, I'm not going to exaggerate when I say that they are economically incompetent. ⁓ the core of their argument is, you know, they look back at slave plantations and they see things like, Well, well, plantations kept accounting books. Well, so did the Soviet gulags. That didn't make them capitalist. ⁓ y you know, accounting is Something that dates back to antiquity in modern accounting, the double entry accounting book practices come out of the banking industry of ⁓ like medieval Italy, ⁓ not slavery. But they point out and say, Well, we have records that ⁓ slave plantations use sophisticated accounting books, therefore they were involved in capitalism. ⁓ and then they stretch that even further. ⁓ so the sixteen nineteen project got in trouble over this because the Matthew Desmond, who's one of these new history of capitalism types, writes for the sixteen nineteen project. He says, If you use Microsoft Excel today, you are using a ⁓ a spreadsheet that is a modernized version of a ledger that comes from the plantation system. ⁓ so everyone that logged into Microsoft Excel, you know, you're you're guilty of perpetuating the exploitation of slaves or something. And you know, you know, I was reading this and I pointed out he actually misread his source from a ⁓ history book about ⁓ accounting on the plantation system. And in the opening chapter, the author of it says. I am not asserting that Excel comes from plantation accounting books. So you just misread the thing. ⁓ and this is like a recurring pattern in this new history of capitalism literature. ⁓ so they point out yes, cotton made ⁓ cotton raw material goes to textile mills in New England and it's made into ⁓ products ⁓ that are sold on the market. Okay, well, raw material exists in capitalist and socialist societies and everything in between. And oftentimes it is drawn out of very exploitative labor practices. I mean, look at China today, very much a formally socialist state that engages in slave labor, essentially. ⁓ go back to antiquity, there are all sorts of instances of slave labor being used to produce economic items, and yet we wouldn't call the Roman Empire capitalist. So there's a very facile argument. That's built up with a ⁓ a pile of jargon and confused terms. And yet you'll notice this in the new history of capitalism literature. I've called several of these people out directly and they have no answer for it. They never define the word capitalism. They want it to be this intentionally ambiguous concept that's floating out there in the ether that basically means everything I dislike, everything that's bad. And then they go into this exercise of trying to backfill the evidence of tying slavery to capitalism. But there's another problem. Because if you asked the slave owners in eighteen fifty, are you capitalists? They probably would have pulled out a gun and threatened you to a duel. They thought that was an insult. ⁓ the slave-owning component of the country adhered to a very rigid economic philosophy that was rooted in anti-capitalism. And they and in fact there are multiple records of this of ⁓ leading slave owners. And pro-slavery theorists, one that I like to point out is a fellow named George Fitzhugh. He's writing in the 1850s. And he publishes two books and dozens of articles that are like the pro-slavery answer to Frederick Douglass and William Lloyd Garrison. ⁓ they're saying, well, why slavery is a good thing? And he becomes the leading figure of that side of the debate. And ⁓ his books don't open, though, by announcing that slavery is the great ⁓ savior of society, even though that's his His perspective, he sa his books open by saying this political economy of Adam Smith and ⁓ the characters that follow in Smith's ⁓ footsteps, they are a conspiracy that's seeking to destroy slavery. And in so doing, they're going to ruin the national economy. ⁓ the free market economists are abolitionists and they have teamed up with the cause of emancipating our slaves. And if that happens Our raw material production in the South collapses, and that will cause the United States economy to collapse and then the global economy to collapse. So that was the argument they were making at the time. We later heard a version of this, it was known as King Cotton Theory at the eve of the Civil War. ⁓ the idea that cotton was so important to the world economy that A, no other nation would dare make war upon it because they'd be like shooting themselves in the foot of ⁓ cutting off their ⁓ source of textiles and economic productivity of their own. And B, if anyone dared to attack the South, well obviously Europe would come rushing to its aid because Europe needed textiles as well. Well, we have a a a natural experiment that unfortunately plays out in a very bloody way between eighteen sixty one and eighteen sixty five called the Civil War that debunks King Cotton theory in real time.
Speaker 1
I just have to say I never learned how to use Excel. So there's no blood or on my hands. ⁓ you know, when you mention these examples, ⁓ it's almost I wonder if people like Jamel Hill and Mark Lamont Hill are they just reading the proponents of like King Cotton?
Speaker 2
⁓ You're free of of the the guilt of slavery.
Speaker 1
No doubt there were people out there making the case for slavery who were white themselves. But it's almost like you have to only read those people and completely just block off all of the more well known
Speaker 2
Well, this is one of the reasons why I say the new history of capitalism school, even though it's ⁓ situated at elite Ivy League institutions, is full of ranks of incompetence, ⁓ ideological incompetence. reason being, you know, not only do they play these word games to redefine capitalism, they do not know the basic literature of the history of slavery. They don't know those debates from the eighteen forties and eighteen fifties when the free market economists, the followers with Adam Smith, were linking arms with the abolitionists. And they don't know people like FitzHue who are denouncing it from the other side. Fitzu, by the way, says, I will show you the world's most perfect iteration of a socialist economic system. It exists in the South on the large plantation systems. It's a centralized economy with a ⁓ that's a microcosm of self-sustaining sufficiency because they're farming their own goods, and there's a master who sets order to the place. But all the slaves are taken care of and they're giving housing and clothing and food for life, and they don't have to be part of the capitalist grind of the ⁓ factory system up in the north. This was Fitch Hugh's argument. And he says, you know, a socialist should embrace slavery. ⁓ they just don't realize it yet. ⁓ now you get you can say, okay, well, yeah, maybe he's going a little bit too ⁓ far there for rhetorical purposes, but I think the analogy is is very similar. If you look at the Soviet Union. You know, it's essentially operating as a slave economy of sorts.
Speaker 1
In a way it's sort of like slavery is the ultimate extreme example of centralized control.
Speaker 2
And that's how the Southerners saw themselves. ⁓ I mean you had a whole genre of economic writings that emerge in the ⁓ the late eighteen fifties that are saying this. And one of this is it comes from the King Cotton speech, which was given by a South Carolina senator. But but he calls it the mudsill theory of society. And the idea is if you are building an economy, you're building a society and a culture, there has to be a foundation level, which in the old times, you know, before they had like modern concrete. They laid what was called a mudsill. And this is the ground level that you put ⁓ before you build the structure on top of it. And ⁓ you know, what he says in the speech is that, well, slaves are the mudsill of society. They're the foundation that allows a greater edifice to emerge from it. And actually, Abraham Lincoln attacks this in several speeches ⁓ when he's running for president and ⁓ and when he's he's coming to the national scene as a figure. ⁓ in he defends free labor in the north as the better economic system to ⁓ this forced coerced labor in the south. And then of course, overlaid on top of this is the pure brutality of slavery. ⁓ you know, all of these pro-slavery anti-capitalist theorists of the eighteen forties and fifties in the south, ⁓ they sugarcoat just the ⁓ the sheer terror of what's happening on the plantation system, just as the Soviets sugarcoated what was happening in the gulag system. ⁓ so very similar parallels going on there today, but bring it back to the new history of capitalism people, these academics that someone like Mark Lamont Hill is listening to. ⁓ some of these media figures are repeating on national TV and in the 1619 project. Well, this is why I say they're incompetent. Read Ed Baptist's book from 2014 or so called Behalf Has Never Been Told. This is like the ⁓ the Bible of the new history of capitalism literature that links supposedly links slavery to capitalism. Well, he goes through this exercise in the book where he purports to calculate the share of US GDP that comes from cotton production. But the problem is he doesn't know basic economics 101. He doesn't know that how GDP is calculated. And this is something I used to teach in my macro classes on like the day one lesson. What's GDP? It's a statistic that measures all of the economic output of the country or the state or the economy in the in the course of a year. It's a tabulation. It's just an accounting tool. Adds everything up. But there's some rules in how we do accounting. And one of those is we only count finished goods. We don't count the intermediate steps. So if I'm making paint and I sell it to Ford and they spray that paint on a car, ⁓ that doesn't count as a sale of paint on top of the sale of the car. Only the car itself sell ⁓ counts to GDP. Well, ⁓ so if you're doing that historically, and this is a basic statistical practice, cotton usually is not a finished good unto itself in the eighteen fifties. And what someone like Ed Baptist does is he counts all these intermediate steps in the numerator and he doesn't adjust the denominator, which is just the baseline of GDP. And he comes up with through like bad math, ⁓ multiple, ⁓ double, triple, quadruple counting of all these steps. He comes up to the point and he concludes, well, slavery in about 1850 was a full half of the United States economy's GDP. And you're reading this, you're like, what? It it just doesn't make sense. And several economic historians, myself included, recalculated the figures. And we find out that you know, if you did the adjustments properly, it's actually about six or seven percent of GDP, not fifty percent of GDP. So these historians don't even know what they're talking about. They're making basic egregious errors in these supposed award winning books, and then they get picked up by Nicole Hannah Jones, Matthew Desmond, Mark Lamont Hill, these media figures, and repeated as aha, this is proof that ⁓ slavery and capitalism are wetted at the hip. Completely oblivious to the empirical evidence and completely oblivious to the historical intellectual history of people like George Fitzhew trying to bury Adam Smith's economics because Adam Smith is an abolitionist.
Speaker 1
What the process like to correct an error like that? I I would imagine if you were a an academic in good standing with integrity, you would say, ⁓ fifty percent is a lot larger than six or seven percent. I really need to offer an apology or something like that, or
Speaker 2
Academic integrity. I mean, there's a there's an oxymoronic term. ⁓ and I think we've actually seen this in having because people have confronted Ed Baptists about the statistical error. And he he actually was given an opportunity to revise the book for a paperback edition. Of course he doesn't. And several economic historians, including some that kind of lean to the center left, call them out for his errors. And his response was to accuse them of racism, to say, well, you're underplaying slavery. And they're saying, No, we're we're just doing the stats, and the stats don't show what you're claiming. But he ⁓ so so it's a complete dodge for his own error. And to this day, neither Baptist, ⁓ nor Sven Becker nor Seth Rockman, any of these boosters around him are willing to grapple with the empirical evidence that undermines their theory. They just double down and they play word games, semantic games, and shift the definition of capitalism, ⁓ shift the parameter, shift the goalposts of what's even being measured, and come up with a different conclusion. So ⁓ you know, I think mo most recently I saw Beckert was peddling this alternative statistical paper instead of looking at GDP as the the whole US economy. He's like, well, well, let's look at slavery's share of agriculture. That's going to be a much bigger share because slavery was almost entirely an agricultural enterprise in that era. And it's like, okay, well, yes, but well, what's agriculture share of the full US economy? Turns out that your statistic collapses once again. And yes, that that's the pattern that plays it. So it's a continuous game of battling with these people. Over shifting goalposts overlaid with the fact that they just do not understand the historical literature, they're really pushing an ideological agenda.
Speaker 1
So this probably helps to answer the question, did America become an economic powerhouse because of slavery? Well
Speaker 2
Well, ⁓ you know, the basic stats are there. If only six percent of US GDP was tied up in cotton, ⁓ then the answer is pretty plain plainly no. Now if you expand it to other areas where slave production, you can maybe get to nine or ten percent of GDP, but still, again, the answer is no on an empirical basis. Now, like the social historian is gonna look at that and goes, ⁓ but you're missing something. Slavery is also a hugely exploitative system and it's a national political problem, and in both of those Claims, I would answer yes, it absolutely is. But the question is, what does it do economically? And our best evidence shows that in fact slavery was a profitable enterprise up until the eve of the Civil War, but with several caveats. One, it was profitable only to a very, very small number of ultra-wealthy elites in the South, the plantation owners. Second, that profitability was tied up in the fact that they had secured massive public subsidies for themselves from the government. Maybe asking well, well, how is slavery subsidized? Well, the federal government nationalized the enforcement of fugitive slave rendition. It passes the Fugitive Slave Act that basically enlists a a national police force to return escaped slaves to the South. That's a huge enterprise. They also build fortifications and military installments all over the South. Why? To have them there on hand to put down a slave revolt. They censor the mails and the post office ⁓ to prevent abolitionist literature from reaching slaves. There's another public expenditure. You can go down this whole long list of ways that the federal government of the United States had assumed through slave owner rent seeking the enforcement mechanisms of this enterprise. And there's an argument, and I think it's a pretty powerful one, it comes from my friend Jeff Hummel. He says if you take this away, you take away the subsidies. The whole slave system collapses because well, what do ⁓ people that are imprisoned against their will tend to do? They tend to try to escape. They flee to the north. And if there's no fugitive slave act to force them back into slavery, well, the whole system collapses and suddenly the slave owners themselves have to assume the costs of running like a prison camp around their plantations. ⁓ so you've got that dimension in there. Then you have other economic indicators going on about where's the vibrancy of the U.S. economy in that era. It's all in the north. The North is growing faster. The North has industry, whereas the South does not. North has more railroad mileage, better transport. The South is really kind of the backwater of the U.S. economy in the two decades or so before the Civil War. And actually, some of the Southerners were starting to realize this and write about it. It was like, uh-oh, we're being left behind by the North. Another indicator, you look at where people, when they get off the ship from Europe, immigrants, where do they go to settle? It's the Ohio Valley, it's the Midwest. ⁓ some of them go all the way out to California and the West Coast. They go to the free states. People don't decide to move to places that ⁓ you know, are economically impoverished where there's no opportunity to start up, especially if you're you're an immigrant, you're right off the boat, you all that you're you Own is basically what you're carrying in your pocket. You don't move to Charleston, South Carolina if there's no economic activity there, but you do move to Cleveland. And that was the pattern that had emerged in the decade or so before the Civil War. So you see people voting with their feet, they're going where the economic activity is. And then finally, after the Civil War, ⁓ there's clear empirical demonstrations of this. Even down to the county level, counties that had a higher percentage of slave plantations in them before the Civil War lagged economically for decades, well into the 20th century, behind the rest of the country. And you know, i i i if this had been the engine that was driving capitalism, that should have been on the top. Like the wealth should have remained there. And in fact, like the abolition of slavery after the Emancipation Proclamation, it should have caused an economic recession if any of these theories were true. And in fact, the opposite happens. Yeah, all
Speaker 1
Ultimately, if someone is making the case that the US's wealth is predominantly based on slavery, you're kind of making an argument for slavery.
Speaker 2
It's a it's a roundabout it's quite strange.
Speaker 1
I could imagine there being a a kooky congressman or congresswoman coming out and saying, Well, look, the economy is lagging. I know what we need to do. We need to look back on our history and we need to bring back slavery.
Speaker 2
It it's ⁓ yeah, I this is why I say the new history of capitalism people, they stumble backwards haplessly and ineptly into king cotton theory. And none of them has an answer for that. ⁓ you know, ⁓ you raise the issue with them, it's like, well, wait, you're just regurgitating arguments from the eighteen fifties by George Fitzhugh and ⁓ and these other King Cotton theorists, ⁓ and they they look at you with like dear in the headlights and then they switch gears, they shift the goalposts and then they accuse you of being racist 'cause you don't accept their version of capitalism.
Speaker 1
On that note, I I don't think we've defined capitalism. I mean I'm right, right. And and let's not, you know, commit the fatal error that the enemies of capitalism make by not not defining it. And going back to CNN with ⁓ Camille Foster, who turned to ⁓ Adam Smith as a as a way to define capitalism. And I'm I am paraphrasing Camille Foster's paraphrase of of Adam Smith, but when I think of capitalism, I think of a a system of private property. And the freedom to voluntarily exchange goods and services with those around me.
Speaker 2
Yeah. So I I like the Deirdre McCloskey definition as kind of an alternative to capitalism, which is a loaded term, but she calls it trade tested betterment. ⁓ you know, this market exchange is actually not a design system from above. This is what distinguishes it from socialism, which is a a designed order, but capitalism, ⁓ you know, it's an organic system of exchange. Under certain conditions that must exist. And one of those is the existence of private property. But that property includes ownership over the self. You own your own work and your body and your ⁓ your life. You you have a choice in your career. In other words, free labor itself is an implicit core concept of capitalism. You cannot have a true capitalist system without the freedom. To ⁓ trade the products of your work and your ⁓ your efforts as you own them. ⁓ the freedom to leave your job if you don't like it and go try something else and go innovate in another direction. So you need free labor to have capitalism. And this is one of the points that the n the Northerners were making on the eve of the Civil War. It's also one of the points that Fitch you tries to rebut and says, Well, these northern factories. That's just wage slavery, just ⁓ exploitation of the workers. And FitzHue actually comes really, really close. He's writing a decade and a half before DOS Capital comes out from Karl Marx, but FitchU develops a theory of surplus value, the difference between what the factory owner takes in and what he actually pays in wages to ⁓ his employees. And FitchU says, ⁓ well, ⁓ he doesn't call it surplus value, but he does the same calculation that Karl Marx does. He says, Well, the difference there. That's being exploited. It's being stolen by the factory owners, the owners of capital, and kept from their ⁓ their workers who are actually producing ⁓ the goods and and creating the value. And he says that's exploitative. But he says, Aha, I have a system that'll solve it. If we just bring the plantation slavery system to the factories and just repurpose the model up there, we've solved it because now ⁓ the factory owner ⁓ is in charge of providing housing and clothing and medicine and care for all his workers. And this is the way to go. It's the perfect socialism.
Speaker 1
And it's the thing that we don't want here at Happy Hour Econ. We hope you enjoyed this episode. Come back next week where we are going to dive a little deeper into the economics of slavery.
Listen & Watch
Share This Episode
Pull up a stool with Lou and Phil
Next
Round's
On Us
New Episodes, Straight to Your Inbox. No Cover Charge.
No spam, just good economics served with a side of laughs. Unsubscribe anytime.