27:17
The Campaign Hangover
Hosted by Lou Perez and Phillip W. Magness .
A Free To Choose Network production.
Show Notes
The midterms are over, and if your phone, mailbox, and TV seem a little quieter, there’s a reason: the most expensive midterm cycle on record just turned off the tap on text blasts, attack ads, and glossy mailers. So where did all those billions actually go? Why would anyone spend that much chasing a political office, and what is a single vote really worth? Nurse your election hangover with Lou and Phil on this week’s Happy Hour Econ.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and may contain errors.
Read Transcript
Speaker 1
Welcome back to Happy Hour Econ, where a comedian and an economist walk into a bar. I'm Lou Perez, the comedian. So we just got through the latest rounds of midterm elections, and it is on record as being the most expensive in history. We're talking about eleven point nine billion dollars. And I had no idea that that was the case when I went to my polling station around seven thirty AM with my son. and cast my ballot. Bill, that money i it gets spent on something. Where's it going, man?
Speaker 2
Well, you know, I I guess in my own experience, I got flooded with spam text messages, and each of those costs probably a couple cents per campaign. I get YouTube ads for candidates that I couldn't even vote for because they're in other states. I get flooded with TV ads and radio ads, and then my mailbox gets filled with garbage every day, coming from dozens of different campaigns all begging me to vote for them. so yeah, that there's a lot of spending on Junk mail, junk ads, spam techs, spam calls, useless drack from an economic perspective. And then I guess it all ends up to about $12 billion.
Speaker 1
I'm amazed that it's like the only mail that I've gotten seemingly this whole year is just like this person is running and it's like you don't want to vote for the other guy. Even though it's mail, I can still hear like the music that they use, the haunting music and like the terrible commercials. I've just been inundated with ads the last few weeks or months. And I'm just wondering, like, are the local news stations and media companies or the ones selling the ads, like, are they the ones cleaning up? on all of this? they must they must love it.
Speaker 2
Yeah. Yeah, I I think there's certainly an advertisement surge, although it's probably not quite as much as one would expect as something else would fill that slot. they just have a diversion of resources over into political stuff instead of the local furniture store or used car salesman. So you've got that going on. You also have a political consultant industry, which turns out to be it's pretty large. these are are people who their their entire job is that they go year to year working for campaigns. And they do everything from writing press releases and messaging and strategizing and polling and all that sort of stuff down to you know the grunt work of recruiting and managing volunteers or standing in front of polling places and passing out more of these junk mailers that you otherwise would get in your mailbox. All that stuff is pretty expensive and it adds up. And the question here, you know, it's not so much is this economic activity? It it very obviously is. you know, this goes into paying people's careers. The print company that makes the signs and makes the brochures is economically benefiting from the fact that there are campaigns out there. But it's also a question of compared to what? What would this money otherwise be used for? And I think as more broadly symptomatic, politics itself has become a resource allocation mechanism for public monies and public benefits. Control of the government and Get stuff sent to you. And as long as that exists, people are willing to move money in the private sector out of productive economic activities and dump it into campaigns to spam your cell phone with text messages for six months straight going into the election.
Speaker 1
Eleven point nine billion, that's an accounting of the money spent. Just think about all of the free advertising that's going out there because everybody is talking about one campaign or another. I mean, live in New Jersey and I think I've seen more ads about Michigan's elections than I have about my own local elections. Yeah.
Speaker 2
It's a it's turned campaigns into a nationwide phenomenon. And I think this goes deep into some constitutional changes over a hundred years ago when we went to the direct election of senators and made all Senate races a national contest where they are recruiting donations from a nationwide pool and they're spending them in ways to shape nationwide opinion with the hope that that comes back and influences Michigan or Texas or wherever the hot race happens to be that year.
Speaker 1
And I know a few people over the years who lived in New York but had a residence in quote unquote swing state. And they were so proud that they were going back home to their swing state to do to vote. To vote and to do the boots on the ground stuff. And I mean, it kind of makes me just think way too much depends upon who's in office, right? I like it seems like so much can change depending on who's voted in.
Speaker 2
So you got one side this kind of race to the bottom of throwing money at campaigns, and campaigns really operate on the margin. they're asking the question it's it's Monday night before the election. What if I had done that one more mailpiece to gone out? what if that one more ad by had hit the airwaves and I turn out to lose a close election on election day? You're always second guessing. Well What could I have done differently? so there's an incentive here to really spend up to the maximum amount at the end, even if the marginal return for that is just a few votes. or some of them may even backfire. We have all these instances, you know, ads are hard to predict how they're going to be received by the public. And there have been a couple in this cycle where a candidate, both parties have done this, ran a really boneheaded ad that just angered people and and caused a backlash against them. And yet they're spending the same amount as they would if that was a really good app to get it on the air. It's the same price on there. but the decision is made on the margin. You up your ante to try to carry yourself across the finish line and win with a comfortable victory, because there's some a lot of uncertainty around there. Who's going to turn out on election day? Is it going to go in your favor, especially in the close races? So you've got that on on one side. But here on the other side, what's the value of your vote? It's statistically Negligible. not to be a downer here. You are more likely to die in a traffic accident on the way to the polling place than to be the guy who cast the vote that changed this the election in the outcome that you desire. That's just a statistical fact. And it's depressing. I wish
Speaker 1
I had known that before I got in my car and drove to the polling place. If I remember that that would have changed my whole morning.
Speaker 2
The silver lining here is both are are extremely rare events. it's like getting struck by lightning. Yes, it could happen, but it's like one in a million or one in a billion chance that it happens. Yes, you could get in a in a car accident going to McDonald's for lunch, but it's an extremely rare event. So therefore we accept the risk. But statistically speaking, the chance of you affecting the outcome of a a a major election with your one vote. It's negligible. It's like hitting the lottery. It never happens. you know, I even like it. It's hitting the lottery, but all the prizes are terrible even if you do win, because you just get politicians, not a payout.
Speaker 1
No on the ballot there were people running for a school board and there were three positions in the school board and there were only three people running. And I actually went, I wrote in my name and my wife's name, and my wife said we better not win. it's obviously a you know more of a a local thing, but apparently like things are are so toxic, such a toxic environment on the local school board that nobody wants to be Part of it and just looking at forget about the actual ins and outs of governance, it's so toxic just running for government, and for running for political office, the amount of stuff that comes out about people's past, their relationships, the stuff they want to keep hidden, the stuff they don't want to talk about, the stuff we insist on talking about. It's so ugly.
Speaker 2
It's like the incentives are aligned to attract and curate the worst possible people in the world as politicians for political office. In other words, it it it attracts people who have a very, very high tolerance for mudslinging and getting dirty and into the gutter in their campaigns. And they have a very high tolerance for being called names. you know, it's the guy that gets caught on video doing something horrible. And that video becomes the opponent's campaign ad and he just kinda shrugs it off and says, Well, what are you gonna do? Vote for the other guy? Right. So yeah, there there's it's it's the Hayekian principle, Friedrich Hayek point. Why do the worst get on top? And it's because they're the least scrupulous. They're the people that have a lower social aversion to things that normal people think are bad.
Speaker 1
with this much money involved, nearly twelve billion dollars this time around, is is this evidence that our campaign finance system is broken? is this
Speaker 2
People always say that they hate too much money in politics, but they hate too much money when it's the other guy spending it. yeah. When when it when it's their side spending it, it's righteous money. so there's there's some psychological effect that's going on here on on the way that people excuse it. And again, it because it's it's always like this race to the bottom to spend the marginal dollar to win your campaign, it's not really a skew in any sense, so much as it's both parties. Are trying to collect the political rents that are available for taking through public sector decision making. If winning a Senate seat delivers on the goods by bringing it back to your home state or or in a contract to your company, you'd be willing, logically, to spend up almost up to the total amount that it takes to win that seat, because you still end up ahead. If your calculus is, hey, my guy wins, I get the contract. Well I'm still a net ahead if I spend massive amounts of money to try to make that winning happen. And this is so this is the point that Gordon Tullock and some other economists make is referred to as rent seeking. It's political campaigns attract rent-seeking behavior. This is the reappropriation of economic resources into chasing political office. And in a pure rent-seeking scenario, the amount of resources that they're willing to dump into that or win all the way because they they they they reach the actual value, the expected value of what the political win delivers to them. if their guy wins. and the other twist to it is is, you know, if you you donate to a campaign and that candidate loses, you don't get a refund on your donation. Right. Right. It it's so so it's economically wasteful in that sense. It it removes productive ac activity and resources from the private sector business economy and reallocates them into seeking political favors, all for the disbursement of other political favors. Now, what do you do about it? Well, I said, well, we should just regulate campaign finance. well that runs into all sorts of constitutional issues because that's like saying, well, we're gonna fix the mudslinging problem in a campaign by regulating free speech. So the solution ends up being worse than the illness itself.
Speaker 1
Yeah, I I always find the the people who say we need to get money out of politics, it's always the next election. And with that I wonder, you know, is there like a true one to one comparison that spending more money actually works? I mean, can you take a bad candidate with a bad message and spend your way to a victory?
Speaker 2
there are instances on the local level where people have so called bought a a state representative seat. may they they just flood these tiny primary elections where you may have ten thousand voters and that yet they're spending millions of dollars in the least efficient way possible. You know, if it were legal, it would be more economically efficient for the rich guy to just mail a check to every voter and and and say, well, hey, I I got A thousand dollars in the mail, but instead they'll spend ten thousand dollars per voter on campaign ads. It's a really wasteful way of allocating resources. And we see instances of this, especially in the primary season, where you you take a even a national candidate and you can run the calculation and see how many votes did they get per dollar spent. And the levels are just absurd, ridiculous. especially in losing campaigns. They are spending millions of dollars to get you know, not bang for their buck, but that's because it's the only route to do it. we don't want the alternative of just bribing voters, even though that might even be a l a a more efficient way of of achieving it. I'm not advocating this but just noting the economic principle in the abstract.
Speaker 1
gonna ask you, is it legal to sell one's vote? Because when you talk about bribery, there's direct bribery, like you you just said, write a check or I would prefer cash actually. Let's be real here. Versus politicians promising voters the world. the the the amount of money that politicians promise voters versus how much they would actually give if they could give directly I think it's a pretty big difference. Yeah.
Speaker 2
Yeah, well that's the thing, is because bribing voters directly is generally illegal. there were instances historically the founding fathers, they invented these these great tactics where, if you showed up at the polling place and you voted for your candidate, they'd hand you a beer or a glass of whiskey or they'd they'd pay you off in booze. that was the old historical way to do it. you know, there are records of George Washington doing this, like celebrating his victory by making sure his voters were well equipped with libations.
Speaker 1
Very drunk fodders.
Speaker 2
Very, very drunk voters. So th you have that history, and I guess that was kind of a form of bribe. but it a as things have moved in a more above the board way, as as outright bribery has become illegal and frowned upon and and viewed as unethical, which, you know, I think that's there's a fair case that it is. What it means is roundabout bribery through Bringing home the bacon to your district or political favors has increased the pork barrel side of that. Only you just do it after the election in terms of the bills you pass. And I I think what this all goes to is toward a as a lesson, is you know, I'm gonna make a normative point here, but our government is too big, does too many things, and disperses too many favors through the public sector. That makes winning an election More valuable than it should be.
Speaker 1
Mm-hmm. It's more valuable to them for sure than than probably to little you and me. I do wonder, do candidates hosting rallies, you know, do they bring a benefit to the community and business or you know, do they drain resources too?
Speaker 2
I think there's a opportunity for a study here. I should get one of my economist friends on it. Is when because you know they do all these analysis when the Super Bowl comes to town, does it fill up the hotel rooms around it? Could you ask the same question? When President Trump comes through with the rally or when the the opposing side comes through with the rally, does that fill up the hotels around it and draw people to the businesses? I suspect that the economic effect is is fairly similar. And political conventions are the classic case of this, is We go to Philadelphia for the Republican Convention. We go to New York for the Democrat Convention. And there are these big flashy extravaganzas. They even rent out the sports arena. They roll out the red carpet. It's like Hollywood for ugly people. McLean is, well, we're bringing economic activity to the local economy, but they never ask, well, what's the unseen there? What would these people be spending that money on if it weren't a sequin adorned hat with Uncle Sam on the top of it? It's you know, I probably wouldn't expect an average person to buy that as their everyday wear, but they'll buy it because they want to go to the convention and cost
Speaker 1
you in full disclosure, I have performed at a number of libertarian party conventions. So not as wealthy as you know the the mate the two major democratic parties, but you know I I I played my role in the whole circus, that's for sure.
Speaker 2
Yeah, major parties there in New York City, libertarians are like Dayton, Ohio.
Speaker 1
Yeah.
Speaker 2
Yeah. It's that sort of thing. So maybe you're bo boosting the local economy at the small again, it's just like the sporting events. There's a claimed seen benefit, but there's an unseen benefit because every time one of these conventions occurs, it just diverts resources from something else. It's next best use is
Speaker 1
something else that happens where I think if you're in a room full of people who are, you know, for the most part your ideological friends, it could also trick you into believing that everybody outside of that room also believes what you believe. Now, granted, again, full disclosure, I've been I, you know, Libertarian Party, we know where we are. We know we know where where we are
Speaker 2
Yeah, where we the only it's like the only honest political party out there, at least about its prospects. Right. Right.
Speaker 1
but I I feel like, you know, in a in elections passed and you know, in particular with say like, you know, the Donald Trump campaigns, a lot of Democrats were just completely taken aback that this man could have won these elections. I think because they were kind of in the bubble of living in communities where everybody was voting one way and not being able to see beyond beyond themselves, outside of those bubbles, right? Yeah.
Speaker 2
This even has a name in in kind of the formal literature is called the Pauline Cale effect. You know what was this A Pauline Cale was this this film critic and and she she's alleged to have said this, although like it's it's apocryphal as well. As the other other interesting thing is she got misnamed is it was after Richard Nixon won, I think in nineteen seventy two. She was alleged to have said to her friends this well, I don't know how he won because I don't know anyone that voted for him. And the claim here is, well, My social circle, the people I hang out with were all against Nixon, and yet he won. it's like a disconnect caused by the echo chamber. And in fairness to Pauline Kale, if she never said that, if it's apocryphal, her name's been attached to it. And yet we see instances of this everywhere in politics. I went to the Trump rally, therefore I know he's going to win, because you saw the energy in that room. Or I went to the Democrat rally and I know they're going to win because he saw that energy in the room. Well, you're you're sampling a segment of society that's already disposed to your side or your position. And that's a miss sampling. That's a it's not a representative swath of the full electorate. It's a swath of people that are also at that rally for the same reason you are because they support that candidate already. you're preaching to the converted already. And and if that's your only social circle, you're gonna take the wrong message away from that. And that's where we see, I I I get into these debates about polling, and polling's an imprecise science, but it's a science nonetheless. It's an attempt to approximate the whole population's range of statistical opinions, and yet you'll hear people say, I don't believe the polls. They're all wrong because my my my local friend circle down at the bar, we're all voting for this one guy. And the polls say he's gonna lose, but my friend circle says he's gonna win. Well, what you're doing here is you're you're you're just engaged in bad statistical inferences. And it turns out that if you look at the overall averages of polling, yes, they get it off by a few percentage points here and there. They they miss some races. They're not a hundred percent perfect, but the overall average tends to be pretty close to the long term trend, all for that reason. Yeah, I
Speaker 1
I wonder who's showing up to the polls? Are more people voting this time around? Because I wonder if this, overkill of messaging, if it's making people tune out or people who didn't care in the first place weren't going to show up. I it seems like generally the same amount of people are voting each time around, right? Or maybe I'm wrong.
Speaker 2
And it varies. So midterm elections tend to be lower than presidential years. And then also the incumbent party in midterms, they often have lower energy going in because, they're already in power. Whereas the other side, they're angry at whoever's in power. And it's easier to get their voters motivated into the polls. but then a lot of the spending is just tactics to try to offset those natural effects that occur. based on the cycle of the race and based on who's in power. So if you're you're an incumbent party and you have that midterm disadvantage, well you really should be trying to spend money to get your base out to the polls and energize them. if you're the outsider party that's trying to retake control of something, you want to capitalize on that anger. And that that means, you know, did the heated rhetoric and all the the other usual tactics to get people riled up and out to the polls. so Yeah, really interesting dynamics that come about from that. And it swings and pivots cycle by cycle. but at the end of the day it's a turnout game of which party does better at getting their voters there.
Speaker 1
Is there, you know, a theory or kind of a step by step study about what actually works to get more voters out there? Because one thing that I always found really funny is I remember with like MTV and P. Diddy with like voter die and like get out get out the vote and all this stuff. What was so funny was having like Leonardo DiCaprio be like, just get out there and vote. It's like, no, you don't want your your political enemies voting. You want them staying home. So like just be honest. I mean For the most part, it's like if I'm gonna get what I want, sure, I want more people voting from my side, but if I'm gonna get screwed, I don't want it. I don't want them. I'm on staying home. Yeah.
Speaker 2
It's like this civic duty stuff. I think it's actually your civic duty to not vote, because most voters are completely ignorant and most races down the ballot. And you know, there's a my friend Jason Brennan makes this argument that the ethical decision in voting, because voting affects people's lives and affects their government. If you are voting from a point of ignorance, you know, that's kind of socially irresponsible. And think about it, you know, most people will go into the polling place. They know who the presidential candidates are. They probably are reasonably well informed, even if it may be skewed. But do they know who their dog catcher candidate is? Do they know who their local school board candidate is? Their local tax assessor? All these these way down ballot offices. And there are several studies, both anecdotal and statistical, that they look at these way down ballot races, and the average voter, by the time they get to that, first off they're bored, because they filled out twenty other election. Items before they get to dog catcher. and then they look at it and they have no idea who either of these candidates are. So they vote based on cues. And one of those cues is, well, they can pick the party and they say, well, this guy's a Democrat, I voted Democrat up above, so I'm gonna do that. This guy's a Republican, I voted Republican up above, so therefore. But that doesn't always work because some of these races are nonpartisan and some of them are from localized primaries that are on completely different issues than the national ticket. So what are the other cues that they pick up on? There are recorded instances where people will vote for a candidate who has a s a name that sounds like a celebrity. And you get the dog catcher who happens to share a name with Dolly Parton, right? But is not the real Dolly Parton. It's and there are even instances of this where they pick. Dead celebrities, celebrities that have passed away. So if you have a a a famous name and you want to run for local office, you could take advantage of that. there are other instances. There was a real notorious one that happened, I think it was a Supreme Court justice in Texas in the nineteen seventies, where the guy that ran for Supreme Court Justice had the same name as the former US senator from Texas who had left office a few years prior. And people go to the ballot and say, well, the the senator, now he's running for justice in the Supreme Court. So they voted him in. And it turns out that this guy's like a con artist who was just trying to get into political office so he could collect his salary, and he gets involved in all these scandals. And I think they they chased him down and they found he had run off to an island in the Caribbean to avoid an FBI indictment. And the sole reason he wins. Is because he had the same name as the former senator and people thought that he was the same person. And you know, lo and behold, we have some of that trickery this year. I think it's the Alaska Senate race where one of the candidates has a common name, Sullivan. And
Speaker 1
Right, right.
Speaker 2
and then they they have this interesting rank to order voting system, so it's a little bit different up there. But the opposition candidate found another person who had the exact same name and it's like Daniel J. Sullivan versus Daniel K. Sullivan or something like that. And Now there's all this confusion of which Sullivan are you picking when you vote for and it's all obviously it's an attempt to divide this guy's vote.
Speaker 1
Sometimes dirty politics can also be kind of hilarious if you think about it. we we started off, you were talking about all the text messaging you've been you've been getting. has a political text message ever changed your mind or who you're voting for, or anybody anybody out there really, if you're listening to Happy Hour Econ, let us know which text message.
Speaker 2
The unsolicited text messages fill me with rage. And the more that I get them, the less likely I am to support that candidate, even if I were to agree with them. Well, first of all, my my vote's like inconsequentialist. Statistically it's not gonna change the outcome. But you know what? A way to really anger me, send me a bunch of spam text messages telling me that like the future depends on me voting for Joe Schmoe for dog catcher.
Speaker 1
Well, you heard it, folks. All you politicians out there, stay away from Phil. Quit blowing up his phone with all of your text messages. This has been another episode of Happy Hour Econ. We will be here next week for what could possibly be the next most important election of our lives. We'll see you then.
Listen & Watch
Share This Episode
Pull up a stool with Lou and Phil
Next
Round's
On Us
New Episodes, Straight to Your Inbox. No Cover Charge.
No spam, just good economics served with a side of laughs. Unsubscribe anytime.