Back to Episodes
Artwork for Nobel Intentions

26:49

Nobel Intentions

Hosted by Lou Perez and Phillip W. Magness .

A Free To Choose Network production.

Show Notes

Every October, a committee in Stockholm crowns the year’s top minds in economics with a medal, a royal handshake, and a very large check, all in the name of the man who invented dynamite. But does the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences still carry the weight it once did? Between laureates honored for formulas only a statistician could love and winners who’ve spent their prestige on political punditry, Phil has some notes. And some names. Save a stool at the bar for this week’s Happy Hour Econ, as Lou and Phil hand out a few awards of their own.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and may contain errors.

Read Transcript

Speaker 1

Welcome back to Happy Hour Econ. We're a comedian and an economist walk into a bar. I'm Lou Perez, the comedian. Economist.

Speaker 2

Phil Magnus, the economy.

Speaker 1

So I want to take a moment to congratulate all the Nobel Prize winners this year. Unlike Phil, who is not happy with this year's winners, is it because you haven't won a Nobel Prize yet? Is this a little bit of hater in you coming out?

Speaker 2

You know, I'm still waiting on mine. and I think the interesting thing here, because it does come with a giant pile of money if you do win it. So, you know, that'd be nice. Maybe one of these days for the listeners to our our economics of veganism episode and this theory of conspicuous production, maybe one of these days I'll hold out and they'll recognize my great contributions to that.

Speaker 1

Hey, I was also on that episode. So, you know, Nobel Yeah. There there we go. So you know, before we get into your qualms with the winners, let's talk a little bit about, you know, the Nobel Prize. I mean, who came up with it? Well the

Speaker 2

The original comes out of the will of this this inventor by the name of Alfred Nobel. And the story that's often told is so Nobel was this chemist that invented basically what becomes dynamite, which turns into all sorts of useful industrial products, but it also turns into bombs.

Speaker 1

And what the wily coyote uses at the time to get the road.

Speaker 2

It's it's Acme ordering the dynamite and they have the little plunger thing that blows up the cliff and then it falls on top of him. So he he's a you know s a significant scientific contributor. And then in his will, you he left a portion of his estate behind that was later used to establish this prize. And this is over a century ago. So it's the beginning of the twentieth century. And they create a series of prizes on themes that I guess he cared about. So there's a chemistry prize. there is a prize in literature, and then most famously the prize in peace. And this was you know, the story was this is the the way to pay back for the fact that dynamite's also in bombs. so we we encourage peace. And it's become one of the most prestigious international recognition awards in existence out there, for contributors to the academic fields. I know the Soviet Union tried to compete with it. They created a, I think it was called a Lenin Prize for a while. but this the Nobels really have attained ascendance as the dominant international prestige award for their respective academic fields. Now the economics prize is an interesting one because it's a late comer to the game. it was established in 1969 as a a really long official title. It's the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economics Sciences. From the Speragis Rixbank Prize, which is the the the central bank in Stockholm that basically awards it, although it's chosen by a a committee of experts and economists. So it's created in nineteen sixty-nine as a memorial to commemorate an anniversary of the successor nobels. And they add economics is one of the disciplines that's now honored. I know that there are people out there saying, well, it's not a real Nobel Prize because it wasn't one of the original. For all intents and purposes, the Nobel Committee considers it a a real Nobel Prize. They get the same type of medal, they get the same type of award. And they go over to Stockholm and the the king hands the prize over to them. so I I set aside those conspiracy theory versions of it. but the interesting thing is it's it's become a major component of the economics profession. that internationally now it's the top award you can get for a distinguished academic career in economics.

Speaker 1

How do you win it? is it like America's got talent? I would imagine too, like if you're you know, working in a field like economics, I mean, you're putting probably years and years and years behind some of the work that you're doing. So it's like if you don't win it that year, can you win it the next year for what you've done?

Speaker 2

Yeah, so technically anyone is eligible to be nominated. And it it's a very closed committee and stuff. So they don't really reveal the secrets. It's kind of like electing the Pope. they don't tell, well, well, this guy was the runner up to the conclave. Yeah, it's an internal discussion. And past laureates and winners are thought to have exercised some input, like they could make suggestions for it, but it's it's really the committee itself that makes the decision. Now you'll notice one thing about most Nobel Arts and economics and really every other field, they all tend to be very old. They're often late career, people that are in their 70s, 80s, sometimes even in their 90s, that are receiving a prize in recognition of some major fuel-changing academic work that occurred years or even usually decades earlier. This year's winners, one of them won for a paper basically that was written in 1978. And y you have may ask the question, well, what's going on here? It's an illustration that academic knowledge expressed through scholarly articles is a very slow moving process of dissemination. yes, we recognize in hindsight that this was a major discovery or an important event at the time, but it's taken decades to filter through the literature. And here you are 30, 40, or 50 years later looking back at that paper and saying, well, that was a big deal. Look at all the derivative work that's come out of it. Let's honor that guy.

Speaker 1

Man, I'm just thinking about being old and getting that cash. It's like, I really could have used this cash forty years ago.

Speaker 2

buy the the best nursing home available.

Speaker 1

Find yourself a very attractive nurse who can take the rest of your money. That's the way that's the way I want to go. That's the way I'm planning it. Don't tell my wife or kids. But does the Nobel Prize carry the same weight that it used to? The same prestige?

Speaker 2

There's great debate about this because it it used to be like the hallmark. If you're a Nobel Prize winner, you're you're at the top of your profession. It's considered it's like the calling card that says I'm Albert Einstein or I'm Marie Curie or the the the very pinnacle of scientific achievement, or in economics that's I'm Friedrich Hayek or Milton Friedman or Paul Samuelson. And these do in some respects become household names in the lifetimes of the recipients. because every everyone recognized they they may not know the technical details of what Milton Friedman did on monetary history, but they know that he correctly diagnosed some of the problems that started to emerge in the nineteen sixties and seventies with monetary inflation. And they know him from the Free to Choose series on TV as that econ man that goes and and com explains complex principles and very discernible, understandable ways. so there is a public cachet that builds with that. Now in recent years, I think there are two trends that have dampened some of that, especially in economics. And the first is is really it's not an ideological thing. It's more of a technical thing. The the prize has increasingly gone in recent years to mathematical sophistication. And statistical techniques and coming up with new ways of testing things, coming up with intensive Greek letter laden formulas on how to precisely target some economic indicator, things like that. So it it's it's not typically the accessible form of public communication economics that we saw in one of the early prize winners, which is Paul Samuelson, who, even though he's like a left-wing Keynesian, he was renowned as an economic communicator who could take price theory. And public goods theory and all these concepts that are at the core of the discipline and explain them to the public, which he did by like writing Newsweek columns. where Friedman did, was often kind of a an informal sparring partner in that respect. And then today it's like, all right, well, we we gave a prize to this guy that came up with a fancy math formula for vector auto regression techniques. You you say that to the public and they're like snoring already. Even though it's important academically, our new forecasting technique doesn't really give us much in the term of public cachet. So that's one of the factors. But I think there's a second factor that is ideological, and that's we've had a few Nobel Prize recipients, in economics in particular recently that have you know, for lack of a better word, I said they've behaved badly since they won the prize. They've decided, hey, I won this for academic contributions that were pretty prestige contributions, but now I'm gonna become a public intellectual and just opine on everything on the opinion page of the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times and the you n you name it.

Speaker 1

Before we name names, I just want to remind everyone that this is a podcast produced by the Free to Choose Network. So that means that I am Milton Friedman adjacent. So not bad, not too shabby for a comedian from Queens, New York. Yeah.

Speaker 2

Yeah, we w we can enjoy, hovering in the periphery of his shadow.

Speaker 1

His very tiny shadow. He was a very very small man. I mean

Speaker 2

He was a short man. But should should we name names? I think it'd be more fun.

Speaker 1

let me just tell you guys, if if you're looking for a a fun way to spend your week, go over to on X and see who Phil's fighting with this week. And it's always enjoyable. Grab your popcorn. Let's do it.

Speaker 2

So I think two in particular that come to mind of recent Nobel winners, and recent talking about people that are now very late career and they're very old, but within the past couple of decades, that I think have ruined it for the rest. And the first one we all know our former New York Times columnist Paul Krugman. so who is Paul Krugman? he's a very good economist at his best. he wrote In the 1980s, in particular, very significant contributions to trade theory. They got him acclaim and academic work. He also published a textbook out of it that's very mainstream. it's back when he didn't like price controls and he didn't like the minimum wage because the, this is the mainstream consensus of the field and was a very robust contributor to the science of economics. These are articles with thousands, if not tens of thousands, of citations. like if you want to study trade theory, you read Paul Cripp. Which is great. And that's what he gets the Nobel Prize for. But really about in the late 1990s, he started to move into the profession of political punditry. And at first it's not all that bad. I think he wrote at Slate.com. He was he had a point counterpoint economic topics article, and then he gets hired by the New York Times and suddenly he is like their their left wing columnist and he has a political opinion on everything. And you start to see, some of the opinions that he's expressing in his column align with the Barack Obama administration's position and actually contradict things that he wrote in his textbook twenty years earlier. And there are multiple instances of this. And that you you're sc scratching your head. It's like, well You're purporting to be a a professional economist at the top of the field. you're also touting your Nobel Prize at at every instant. He's not quite wearing it around his neck while he's walking into McDonald's, but it's, you know, it's mentioned all over the place whenever he's quoted in a column. As Nobel Prize-winning economist says Paul Krugman, well, he won it for trade theory, but now he's opining on the minimum wage, or now he's opining on wealth taxes. Things that are outside of his specialty and expertise, but he's using the prestige of the prize to do that.

Speaker 1

When I think of Paul Krugman, one thing that stands out is this quote where he says, It will become clear that the internet's impact on the economy has been no greater than the fax machines. So I don't know if there is a way to take away a Nobel Prize, the same way that if you do something really bad, they'll take away your Heisman trophy. But talk about not getting it right, I guess, on on that one.

Speaker 2

Yeah, that's a pretty big error. And I think this illustrates the phenomenon. Paul Krugman was not a communications economist. He was not a an expert in that sector of the economy. He's a trade theorist. And my message would be like Paul Krugman, stick to trade theory. You're doing great stuff. Venture into fax machine economics and internet economics. And you know, your opinions probably no better than the random guy on the street. It might even be a a bit worse because you Or walking around in a with a smug sense of everything 'cause you have a Nobel Prize now.

Speaker 1

It's so wild how you could be influential and groundbreaking and original in one field and then on something else just not get it right at all.

Speaker 2

brilliant physicist who doesn't know how to tie his shoes. The absent-minded professor. Yeah, yeah, there's and there's multiple instances.

Speaker 1

So who was your your next

Speaker 2

Even worse than Krugman, this is Joseph Stiglitz. And again, he wrote some pretty groundbreaking articles and macro theory and a bunch of other sectors of the field. These are things that have 10,000 citations plus. And he's doing this in like the 1970s and 80s. And, you know, he gets the Nobel Prize, and afterward, he decides he's gonna become a political pundit and a political advisor. and he's very left wing in his personal politics. And he he basically dresses up those personal politics. Into academic prestige now. So, for example, he was one of the major signers of this letter that's been going around on the very far left wing of the profession calling for a global wealth tax. you know, that this is it's like Stiglitz, the Nobel Prize winner, and weird, crazy communist guy from the European University that only writes in the journal of post-Keynesian weirdness. There's something going on here. This is political advocacy. Another thing that that Stiglitz did is around two thousand seven, two thousand eight, he decided he was going to become an advisor to the government of Venezuela.

Speaker 1

I was just about to bring that up.

Speaker 2

He flies down to Caracas and meets with Hugo Chavez. See the picture of this. It exists out there. They've buried it. and he he's advising Chavez on this crazy like Marxist inspired scheme to create an alternative global banking system for the developing world, that is supposedly rooted in Bolivarian socialism. And this is one of these crackpot types of schemes that you know, a random schmo off the street can look at it and say, This is crazy, this isn't going to work. And they go down there or they announce they're gonna launch this bank. Stiglitz is advising it, he gives his stamp of approval, and then suddenly all the all these economists and pundits on the left, well, this Hugo Chavez guy, he's not all that bad, actually. maybe our worst fears we we we can actually admit him into the company of respectable people. Well, we know where Venezuela went. And also it's really interesting if you dig into the history of this banking scheme thing that the Stiglitz endorsed and tried to launch. they dumped a bunch of public money into it and like went into the hands of corrupt politicians and disappeared, and it never happened. So you're you're sitting there like how why what's going on here? This is a guy that's abusing the legacy of his Nobel Prize to engage in left-wing punditry and activism. And including activism that probably was pretty harmful to people, including the people in Venezuela. So that's where I look at bad actors and enough people start seeing these guys. It's like every time the news needs a Nobel economist to opine on something, and it's Krugman or Stiglit spouting left wing nonsense, that's going to ruin the reputation of the prize for everybody that won it, even those that want to stay as far away from politics as they can.

Speaker 1

And I find it interesting if you compare his relationship to the Chavez regime in Venezuela to the relationship, if you could even say there was one between Milton Friedman in Chile with Pinochet. Okay. Where as far as I know, and and you can correct me, basically some guys from the Chicago school went down there and said, Pinochet, you should do this. What I mean is from an economic standpoint, not like, you know, you should

Speaker 2

It's not how to govern. It's not a prescription on on how to run your country's government. Well, and and this is an interesting episode because in the nineteen seventies, Pinochet comes into power through a coup d'etat. He topples a Marxist who was on the track to become a dictator, Salvador Ainde. so it it's a bad situation that's countered by another bad situation. And the these are both pretty ruthless characters down there. They're neither is a beacon of democracy by any means. But Pito Shea initially starts once he seizes power and comes into he runs his government through a a military junta, essentially. And they were engaging in economic policies that were much more the command controls type. And Friedman has like one encounter with him where he says, you know, maybe you should stop hyperinflating your currency. basic things like that. Advice that you'd give to any government in any country. And in fact, Friedman does he Freedman also advises The government of communist China, open your markets, don't do this stuff. It's making your people worse off and and poorer. And you know, he gives this advice to Pinochet, and Pinochet, a few years into his reign enacts some economic reforms that liberalize the market and it actually brings inflation down, it it jumpstart some economic growth. The political system's still authoritarian, but the economic system's starting to liberalize. And Freeman gets blamed by people that don't want the economic system liberalized. it's not like he's creating this crackpot bank of Bolivarian Marxism for Hugo Chavez. It's saying stop doing this stuff that's making your country poorer. And Pinochet says, okay, we'll enact some of those reforms, and lo and behold, it works.

Speaker 1

So we've obviously been very negative thus far. A lot of a lot of hate. How about a few examples of winners who are that you consider like the best winners or underappreciated? Who's on a poster above your bed?

Speaker 2

Well, you know, I I come from a very strong free market perspective. And of the well known ones, let me get my list of Nobel laureates out here. I mean, very obviously Milton Friedman, who I think revolutionizes the field of monetary economics in the twentieth century, one of the most important economic communicators as well in turning complex ideas into digestible, understandable concepts. so he's he's a huge figure in the field and he wins it for legitimate reasons. Really, it's the core of his citation for the Nobel Prize is for his monetary history of the United States. He basically figures out what caused the Great Depression and a whole a bunch of other bad things that happened economically, and it's central bank mismanagement. So that's a big winner there. second one, James Buchanan, who actually knew very briefly. He was very late in life when I was a grad student, met him a couple of times. but he basically co-created the field of public choice economics. This is taking concepts from the private sector in decision making and choice making and asking, well, what's the counterpart in the public sector? What describes how government actors work? And it turns out they're not all altruistic, common good, public virtue-minded figures that are in it for statesmanship and public service, like they claim they are. Public sector actors are often craven, manipulative, corrupt, abusive of the resources they have in control, and susceptible to interest group sway. And Buchanan is basically saying, well, let's study that sector as an economic phenomenon. How are goods allocated and decisions made in the public sector, knowing the actors that we have, not the politicians that we wish we had? And it turns out this explains a lot of bad things that happen. And then he comes in and says, Well, here are some constitutional designs you can impose to limit the damage of corruption and limit the damage of this aspect of self-interested politicians behaving very badly. And then Friedrich Hayek, who's you know, he's my Austrian and my pantheon. Hayek wins the prize. for a variety things. It's a career long prize, although they looked at his the really interesting thing of his career is his examination of knowledge problems and information costs, as we all know. so he he has a very famous article on exploring the dimensions of the use of knowledge, not just economically, but in in general. Like how do we come to understand things? and it's essentially an an anti-hubris of pill. It's a message to other economists like, quit trying to plan stuff because you are not considering millions of other factors out there that didn't even enter into your psyche. And by the way, there's information contained in things like prices that are an amalgamation of tens of millions of historical transaction records that move and fluctuate not through control, but they're conveying signals to you the buyer or you the seller. so there's a lot of great value that comes from that, and then he gets a a prize, it's kind of a recognition of his career. so Friedman, Buchanan, and Hayek, these are probably my three favorites.

Speaker 1

They are the Kirk Cobain, Dave Grahl, and Chris Novoselik. Or or if you guys are more into rush, they're they're the rush of of economics. something I wanted to talk about is you know what impact is AI going to have on these awards? Because you just seen recently it seems like every otherwise impossible mathematical proof that all the geniuses throughout human history have failed to figure out AI's doing it and figuring it out. And the response to it has been interesting. I've seen like mathematicians basically, you know, kind of making the argument, no, we want organic proofs of of mathematics. We want human beings to be the ones who are solving these things. And it's sort of like, aren't you happy that These things are finally getting solved. They're way out of my pay grade, out of my wheelhouse. So I don't even know how this stuff is what it's meant to do or or what it will lead to. but it's sort of like here's real knowledge that is being imparted on humanity for the first time. That sounds great. But also it's like, how do you wouldn't a fields medal, you know, if if your computer's doing it for you.

Speaker 2

Well, it's really interesting. It's like you you plug a a very complex mathematical problem into a supercomputer and then you tell it to bombard it with millions upon millions of attempts to solve it just by statistical probability it'll converge on something. And that's that's essentially what's going on here, which is great. I think this is a great way to advance human knowledge, but it also means it's not the professor on the chalkboard with the the long equation. Written Goodwill Hunting style that the janitor comes and sold or something like that. it's so it's a it's a paradigm shift in that respect. So I think which I think is you know fascinating. Maybe this is the new internet versus the fax machine. it's the AI engine. And I'm sure there's some economists or somebody out there say, well, AI is no different than the C D player or something. bad analogies that that they're throwing out there. But So we have to recognize this is a technological advance. yet at the same time, why were we asking that question that we put into the supercomputer and asked it to solve? Someone had to come up with that somewhere. Yeah. I could ask AI to solve a ridiculous, probabilistic question that is of no value and no use to anybody, and then could probably solve it. But there's a theorem behind what it's being asked to solve versus just generation of of slot art or Or bad music and stuff like that. So I think there's that dimension that's interesting. What what does it mean for the the future of the Nobel Prize? it might have a tempering effect of what I would call the technocrat prizes or the technician prizes, people that are strictly winning because they invented a fancy new statistical technique or they advanced they they solved a mathematical problem that may be very niche. And yet also important to that niche field, yet it doesn't have a lot of general relevance. And it may steer the prize a little bit back more toward the conventional, like the original round of winners for the first two decades or so of the prize. because it's a late comer, it starts in 1969. They had a huge pool of of living economists that have been writing since the 1930s and that they could have honored. so it's like the first several prizes are well. We're gonna give it to Paul Samuelson. He did a bunch of stuff years ago. We're gonna give it to Hayek. He's been writing since the nineteen twenties and he's done all these important things. eventually that pool started to run a little drier as you know people aged out and passed away because you have to be living to win it. there there's one example, William Vickery won the prize and then died like the next week.

Speaker 1

He blew it all in Vegas.

Speaker 2

I guess so. So it's the it's the one of the only examples of a Nobel Prize in economics. but they gave it to him. They called him when he was still alive. He's late in life and then he passes away and I think one of his grad students went and got it at the ceremony for him. But yeah, you have to be living and what it what I think it's done is it's steered toward more technical contributions in recent years and maybe AI tempers that out a bit and you have to have a more Well rounded, broad sweeping contribution to the field, the win in the future.

Speaker 1

no matter what happens, more than anything, I really hope AI doesn't get a hold of dynamite. Coming full circle, I think that might be. So we hope you've enjoyed this episode with two future Nobel Prize winners. We'll see you next week for a whole new episode of Happy Hour Economic.

Share This Episode

Pull up a stool with Lou and Phil

Next
Round's
On Us

New Episodes, Straight to Your Inbox. No Cover Charge.

Sign up to get a quick note each week when a new round (episode) is ready to pour.

No spam, just good economics served with a side of laughs. Unsubscribe anytime.

Happy Hour Econ

Now Playing

Nobel Intentions