26:38
Rebels Without a Cost
Hosted by Lou Perez and Phillip W. Magness .
A Free To Choose Network production.
Show Notes
France is rioting again, which, historically speaking, is about as surprising as a baguette at breakfast. But what actually turns a peaceful protest into a mob setting dumpsters ablaze? It isn’t always righteous fury. It’s often a quick cost-benefit calculation and a shot at a free iPad. Lou and Phil weigh the real price of rioting, from the shopkeepers left holding the bill to the broken window fallacy, so step up to the bar for this week’s Happy Hour Econ.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and may contain errors.
Read Transcript
Speaker 1
Welcome back to Happy Hour Econ, where a comedian and an economist walk into a bar. I'm Lou Perez, the comedian. I'm filming.
Speaker 2
Magnus the economist.
Speaker 1
So there were riots in France again. This time I'm not quite sure what they were about, but but they were definitely happening. why are there riots in France? Phil
Speaker 2
I think first off, this is something France likes to do. if you go back through history, they've been at the riot game pretty consistently since the French Revolution, if not before that. there are more modern ones. So in 1968, there were a wave of student protest riots, mostly from the far left, that mucked up the university system. there was the Paris Commune in eighteen seventy one. there were you remember they had that the yellow vest protesters that In some cases, it spilled over into throwing things around just a few years ago. And there are always labor strikes that happen in France where they'll say, shut down the local train system, or we'll stop delivering baggage at the airport. so kind of a a fluid spectrum of civil disobedience in French political culture that sometimes spills over into more aggressive forms of that, which are riots.
Speaker 1
Yeah, we should probably make the distinction between protest, peaceful protest, and riots, because there are a lot of people we took to the streets who were not violent. Perhaps they didn't have the energy to be violent, but for whatever reason there is a distinction that needs to be made between protesting and rioting.
Speaker 2
And there's the interesting economic implication because, economists will look at this and say there's a tipping point when one converts into the other. protests, most of them are peaceful, most of them have very well defined goals, and yet a few of them descend into something more violent, something more aggressive. And that all comes down to, you know, what's the calculation being made of what's being sought or what they're trying to obtain. Or what that means for crown behavior when you have a mass of people gathered together.
Speaker 1
And this time around, what was the initial protest about? Well it's it
Speaker 2
blurry because it seems like a bunch of different things are being merged in together. I think the the general news report is you have young people that are upset with various things about the education system. And you know, what do we know about kids? They don't they generally don't like going to school. so I think some of that is is a fairly mundane set of grievances and it gets to more substantive grievances where some of them are claiming that schools are underfurnished and haven't been updated. others are just generally angry that there don't seem to be jobs waiting for them when they graduate, whereas the older generations are living at large in the French welfare state that provides them with a lot of job security, provides them with payments if by chance they lose their job, which apparently in France is very, very hard to do because there are all sorts of worker protections in place. And then there are old age pensions that are publicly subsidized. And I I think a lot of people that are in that you know, the the eighteen to twenty year old range, they're graduating what we would consider the equivalent of high school or going into college in France, are looking at the economic landscape and they're not all that enthused or happy with what's existing ahead of them. You know, overlay this with a whole bunch of other problems in France. It's political systems a The governing party has been hit by some corruption scandals, the alternative parties, one of them is the very, very far left socialist. The other's a very, very far right nationalist party. so it's a it's a period of political discontent. And I think both of those factions are mapping some of their own pet issues, i.e., anger at immigration into France is coming from the far right, and then the socialists they're always mad about something. So
Speaker 1
When it comes to this idea of austerity being one of the the problems in France, obviously they want more, you know, more spending and France is too austere. But then when you look at the breakdown about what France spends its money on, a lot of it is welfare programs, no?
Speaker 2
Yeah, yeah. Austerity in the European definition, and I think especially the French definitions, means we continue to spend extravagantly next year, but not quite as extravagantly as we originally planned. It never means actually cutting things down. It never means a reduction in in the budget deficit. It's almost always something's still going up, spending still going up, just not as fast as we want it to be.
Speaker 1
Is that something that the right and the left, at least in France, have in common? It is and it just seems like each party is going to lead to more spending. I mean, at least if I know the United States is very different, but I don't think that spending's going to be cut necessarily in the United States, regardless of whether it's a Republican or Democrat in office. Is that a simpler thing in France?
Speaker 2
I think it's even more pronounced in France because you have both parties, left and right, and then you have this kind of centrist, whatever you want to call it, bloc that's currently governing, the the Macron bloc. they all seem to like spending, just spending on slightly different things. And they all accuse each other of cutting spending on the things that they care about, even though there's not really a cut. And there's not really anyone advocat advocating for like a classical liberal limited government approach. And then you overlay it. There's a massive push right now in France. To install wealth taxes, to to soak the rich. And basically the the same thing they're trying in the United States with Thomas Piketty, again, the French economist that's the ringleader of all this, is a big advocate of putting a new billionaire tax play in place in France. But the the the twist there is they already tried that about two decades ago and it ended up pretty poorly. It chased a bunch of rich people away from France.
Speaker 1
Yeah, when it comes to the wealth taxes, it just seems like businesses, corporations, billionaires especially, are more mobile now than ever. And it's sort of like you don't necessarily have the technology to keep up with them. I mean, it used to be like, Okay, here's you know, before airplanes, I guess, it's like, okay, he's not gonna be leaving the continent. So we can, you know, tax him. But now it's like you could be, you know, anywhere just as long as you have a Wi Fi.
Speaker 2
you moved to New Zealand. Yeah. And that sort of thing happens. I mean, it's just like when California tries it. a bunch of billionaires just by proposing it, putting it on the ballot, a bunch of billionaires started leaving the state. So yeah, you've got that whole problem. And I think there's a mentality issue in France and several other parts of the world that just views the government, whether it's a right wing version of government or a left-wing version of government. as the centerpiece of the economy and as the supposed caretaker of the population. And I look at that and say no matter which ideology adopts it, it's just a recipe for waste, fraud, and abuse and spending a lot of money and getting very little to show for it in return while wearing down the free market system, wearing down the private sector.
Speaker 1
Yeah. And one thing that I think was missing, one detail about riots that I don't think enough people were commenting on was that they seem like they could be a lot of fun if you're especially if you're a young man, you know, with all this pent up testosterone and you need a way to spend this energy. So I wonder when it comes to things like protests, especially leading into rioting, how many of the participants are actually there because they really care about this cause? versus how many of them are there because it's like, I get to break stuff. I get to burn stuff. I might get to to loot. I might get to rob a little bit.
Speaker 2
Get to take a new television home, get to take a new iPhone home. yeah, all these things. Well, and this really gets into the economics of it. And, believe it or not, there is a formal economic theory of rioting. No way. that exists there. Or, read a bunch of old academic papers. And the classic one that I found is by this guy named J. Patrick Gunning. It was written and published in 1972. And the title is An Economic Approach to Riot Analysis. And it turns out that one of the major motives is Well, people engage in rioting because they think they can get free stuff. They can smash the window and take the the fancy purse or the fancy electronic home. It's an interesting analysis. this J. Patrick Gunning, he kind of frames the field, and there have been several other economists that referred to this literature and built upon it and even put it in mathematical models. It asks the question, why do people decide to pivot from just a a normal everyday peaceful protest to start Smashing windows and overturning cars and setting dumpsters on fire. why do they do that? And and it's basically comes down to a cost benefit analysis. And you you think about it. So the the classic like the the fairy tale version of the riot is it's pent-up anger and it's just manifesting as this revolutionary force because people are aggrieved. So what do they do? They have to lash out because they've got no other option. Well, the reality, the economic understanding of a riot is if you have a crowd out there and usually it's triggered by a tipping point that signals to a certain segment of the crowd that, hey, if I do this behavior, the police response is not adequate enough right now to where I'm actually going to get in trouble for it. If I do this, if I snatch something out of the shop window that I just smashed and take it home, I'm probably going to get away with it. Or if I turn over a car or light something on fire or just engage in wanton destruction, the police ch just aren't around right now and there's enough anonymity in the crowd because there's a massive contingent of people around me. well, hey, it's time to go smash things and I'm gonna get some whether it's personal fun out of that or I I go home with a new iPod iPad. You know, it's that sort of of calculus is going through people's heads. And this is almost always a very small minority of the crowd that's out there, but they benefit from the fact that they're absorbed in a much larger crowd. so you may have like 10% of the crowd are bad actors, and the other ninety percent are just there protesting, but that big crowd around there allows them to, you know, smash, grab, and then fade back into the crowd, basically disappear and get away with it. Yeah.
Speaker 1
Well, I know that's one of the tactics with Antifa, where it's the black block. It's like everybody dresses in black and has masks and it's you're this one kind of ink blot that's moving around destroying things, then you move melt back in with everyone else, and you're a lot harder to to catch. And years back I interviewed Theodore Dahlrymple, which is the pen name of is it Tony Daniels, Anthony Daniels? He's with he writes a lot for a city journal and Manhattan Institute. And he was a prison psychologist for a while. And one of the things that he talked to me about when it came to crime and incentives. And he was telling me about how in England, when it comes to burglars, the average burglar will serve something like three days in prison. Right. Yeah. And the question that he was asking was, you know, with those incentives, he was surprised that he wouldn't see more burglaries. Yeah. but it turns out burglars are bad at math and they're not really weighing those Those options.
Speaker 2
Right. Well, the the price tag for three days wages for stealing something that's worth more than three days' wages. so yeah. But and I think you overlay that there are social disincentives to smash windows. I mean, first off, you are going to be very popular if you're in a normal crowd of people and you just start smashing the window in a non-riot situation. Yeah. or you shop list from the store, there's social disapprobation against that sort of thing. there's also cultural norms against it. But we do have known instances when this sort of thing breaks down and it's not always just a riot that follows. It's you know, a mob brand stacking a store. And I know some of these very very closely in particular because you know, I work for a group that's based out in California, the Independent Institute, and we're in Oakland, California, which is not known as the best governed city in America. Is it? it's the People's Republic of Oakland. And One of the things they did, well, California wide, but it was especially bad in Oakland, is they decriminalized crime a few years ago. There's a state proposition, and you know, it said basic basic property crime like shoplifting and things like that. We're just gonna deprioritize policing that. And it was actually a fairly high amount. I mean, you're talking like eight or nine hundred dollars worth of stuff if you're stealing that out of a store, if you're grabbing a laptop or a TV or an iPhone, you know, we're not going to prosecute you for it. So it causes all the stores, they have to up their enforcement, and suddenly everything from your aspirin or your nose spray all the way up to the fanciest electronics or behind a wire cage. But the second thing that happened is you started seeing like these flash mobs converge on a convenience store at two in the morning and just ransack the place. There are all these videos all over YouTube. It's like this is not normal behavior. But they what they realized is a the cost of doing so was suddenly changed. It was very low because the police are probably not going to respond. And then it turns out in some of the most famous incidents, they ransack the store and the owner's calling or the clerk's calling and say, Hey, send the police. I'm being attacked by a mob. And the police don't get there for another six hours. And by then the store is already looted and and all its stuff is taken. and then so you got that. And then the second thing is they're relying on the anonymity of the mob. So they all come in covered in masks and and stuff like that. Well, they're grabbing chips and soda and beer off the convenience store shelf and just running out the door with it. A and you think about this like, okay, you you grabbed like fifteen dollars worth of junk food and groceries, but you wrecked this guy's store, wrecked his livelihood, did actual damage to the property. All the cost is being incurred by someone who's completely innocent here, all because there's been a change in the norms and a breakdown in the enforcement. And I think that same logic you extended en masse to riot. So the people that study like when do protests turn into a riot, they always say there's usually a big tipping point. Major violent event happens. we've seen this is like a police killing that's viewed Sometimes legitimately so is unjust, or some sort of a confrontation incident that goes viral in the media and then suddenly the mobs are out around it and then all it takes are a few bad actors to start smashing things. They grab the stuff and they dissolve back into the mob under the premise that they're probably not going to get caught.
Speaker 1
Yeah. I've been seeing a series of really great AI videos, which the joke is really great. So if you have thirty seconds to spare, you can go watch it. And the the basic title is like Man Stops Shoplifter. So just imagine a a guy grabs a shoplifter who just took say a candy bar and begins to throw him all over the place, just destroying the whole store. So it's sort of like the the you know, the reverse here this guy's, you know, trying to to help and he ends up destroying it. And it's really interesting how stores adapt to, you know, these circumstances. So you have a lot of like big box stores who will not arrest the shoplifter the first time. They will document it. They will get the shoplifter on camera. They will have, you know, whatever technology they use to determine what it is that they stole, and then they'll let the shoplifter basically come back. So you have these repeat offenders and then the bill kind of, you know, piles up and then Once it becomes a you know jailable offense, that's when they get arrested. And it's interesting that that's what they're doing, but it also says a lot about the culture in that wow, we are putting up with a lot of shoplifting up until a point. And years ago, there was a book that came out in defense of looting.
Speaker 2
I remember that book.
Speaker 1
Yeah. And that what I kind of find interesting is is those on the left initiating these protests, initiating these riots. It's like, what capitalists in his right mind will allow you to do this? You know, perhaps the quote unquote capitalists don't have the power that you claim they have if you're allowed to kind of run roughshod over private property and stores and merchandise and and all of that.
Speaker 2
Well well yeah, it it's an assault on norms. And and here's the interesting thing about this. the the the people that def in defense of rioting and defense of looting, all this sort of argument, it comes from the far left. These are people that they look at capitalism as this uniform system and anything and everything against it to tear down that system is is justice. It's right liberating wealth from the the haves and giving it to the have nots. It's emancipatory. It's all wrapped up in this critical theory nonsense that come usually comes out of upper middle class academics that you know have never faced hardship at any point whatsoever in their lives. But to you know set that aside, they're all about repatriating wealth that they believe is stolen by the capitalist system. And yet the reality is, you know, when you steal from a store when you smash its windows when you harm a a shop owner you're not harming capitalism in your house you're you're actually harming that person and that person's normally like a small time business owner who's just trying to make ends meet it's the it's the gas station clerk who's getting paid minimum wage and suddenly is having his entire inventory ransacked and now he's out of a job for the next three months while the insurance comes in and repairs the store. They actually end up Harming the little guy. and again, looted stuff. It's free in the eyes of the rioter. It isn't free to the business owner who has his inventory seized. They're going to have to absorb that in some way or another. It may mean that their insurance premium goes up because they're in a riot susceptible area. And what do they do? Well, they pass that on to their customers in higher prices. Or it may mean some of their inventories. Taken and insurance doesn't pay for it, puts them out of business potentially. Or they leave the area because it's one too many looting mob, one too many riots ransacking. Sometimes they even burn down the private businesses, as we saw during the BLM protests in 2020. you know, real tangible people are being harmed, and most of those people are not the fat cats that the anti-capitalist message seems to claim. that they're striking out against the system. It's usually just a a local, normal person who's in the wrong place in the wrong time or their business happens to be on a street where the mob descends.
Speaker 1
Yeah, some of the most heartbreaking footage f from the latest riots in France were small business owners basically standing outside their business helplessly while, you know, people ransacked it. there was a a woman who I believe she was I believe she was an immigrant. I forget which country she's from, but the immigrant dream of, you know, going to a new country and starting a business was there. There was a there was also a man who basically became memed. He was I think he owned a comic book store in France. and you know, people were, you know, demolishing his stuff. And then there was one that I'm I'm sure a lot of people saw. There was a a woman who was, you know, begging people to leave her store alone. And I I believe one of the things that she said, at least according to the translation, was, you know, I'm I'm with you. I support what you're doing.
Speaker 2
We're gonna you're gonna attack me anyway. Right, right. So so is it ends up actually being self-defeating for you know, if the riot is for this supposed stated objective of better education funding or whatever the cause of the moment happens to be, and then you have these bad actors, well, here's another economic effect of it. When people see this on TV, most of them are revulsed by it. They they look at it just like, you know, this is a breakdown in basic norms of society. It's a great way to ruin popular support for your cause is smashing things and burning things and doing damage.
Speaker 1
Yeah, so what is the political cost? Because I saw a number of people saying, Okay, Marie Le Pen just won.
Speaker 2
Well, i i it seems to be the the political cost seems to drive people toward the extremes. a you know, this again goes back to some of this economic literature on the economic approach to rioting. It's it's hinted at in the gunning article and several subsequent ones that I mentioned. This is, you know, when riots start, there are really only two kind two basic options on how to to deal with them. One is you increase the cost of rioting. In other words, you you ramp up enforcement so high. That the person who thinks they can get away with it by fading back into the crowd with the iPhone tucked in their pocket no longer has that comfort. if they fear they're going to get caught, then the number of people that are willing to riot radically diminishes. But that turns everything into kind of like an authoritarian police state that's sending out the riot guard and declaring a curfew and all these horrible things that are very clear violations of of basic civil norms. so that's bad. the other approach to diffuse a riot is to capitulate to what the rioters want, to pass the public spending that gives them everything they're demanding. But the problem there is A, it's really expensive. B, often what they're demanding is not well defined. It's it's kind of incoherent, as we're seeing in France. It's just an eclectic mix of vague disdain for alleged austerity. You know, you're never going to satiate what the rioters want. And C'est It can create a perverse incentive to other groups with grievances like, well, hey, if all we have to do to get our way is to start smashing things and there's going to be no penalty for smashing things, then we'll try rioting too. You're you're really stuck between two very bad options on that. I'd propose what the third thing is, is this is why a stronger civil norms in society against stealing, smashing, burning, looting are something of a buffer from descending into rioting in the first place, but that has to be built up on a social level, a cultural level over the long term. Again, not all riots are even political. so the ones that I point out, some sometimes you see these instances when a a sports team loses. And the crowds are mad as they're leaving the stadium and what do they do? They start turning the cop cars over. Or if you're in Philadelphia, sometimes it's when the sports team wins. They go and do that to celebrate.
Speaker 1
Exactly. Yeah. And we're so happy. Let us destroy our city. Yeah.
Speaker 2
Yeah. But but but what's going on there? Well again, I think it's a classic demonstration that the economic observation's valid here. People think that in the mob of the moment they can get away with stuff they normally couldn't, and for an act of fun or an act of frustration they can smash things and then they fade back into the mob and they go home and tomorrow morning the city's all smashed up, but they got away with it.
Speaker 1
What is the economic impact of rebuilding? don't
Speaker 2
There's a photo.
Speaker 1
look at it and like you smashed in that whole showcase and that whole window, now that's a job.
Speaker 2
To rebuild it. It it is the classic case of the the old broken window fallacy that's popularized by Henry Hazlitt, versions of it that go back to Frederick Bastiat, the notion that, well, hey, a window's broken, that creates a new job for the glassmaker, which is true, but the fallacy here is it also diverts some resource from some other use that it was intended for prior to the class being broken. So if you have to repair your shop, that may mean your intended upgrade to your showroom next year doesn't happen. Or it may mean that you raise your prices to cover the expenses, or it may mean that you bring in less goods and items in your inventory and your shoppers have a worse experience. Or say you're a small business owner and you were trying to save for that vacation for your family, your store's smashed up in a riot and you have to pay for it. It means your family doesn't go on vacation and Those resources that were previously allocated to other forms of business, buying your plane ticket, the hotel, the taking your kids to Disney World, whatever happens to be, that never happens. So there's a diminishment of other unseen economic activity all caused by the need to repair something that probably shouldn't have been broken in the first place, other than out of criminality.
Speaker 1
And there is a Disney World in France, is isn't there?
Speaker 2
There is.
Speaker 1
Well, two things, when you bring up Bastiat, I would love to hear what Bastiat thinks about these riots. He's probably like, here we go again. And what he thinks about Disney. I think there would be yeah something there. I wonder, you know, is there anything that Americans can learn looking over at France? You know, is there if we had a competition of who does rioting better, we dealt with some really crazy stuff some some years back. I hope that we learn from it. Right and we don't see it again, but Yeah, what what are the the lessons if if any? Yeah.
Speaker 2
I think the the the biggest one is this a lose lose proposition for almost everyone involved. there's no real good way to fix a riot. it's costly because it erodes at social norms. it also has a clear economic costs. And then the rioters, you know, it's a very disorganized, hooligan style way of trying to get what they want, often under a political pretext, but that political pretext is really I just wanna grab a new pair of sneakers and new electronics and jewelry. Well wherever you
Speaker 1
are right now. We hope you're not riding, or at least you're taking a break from rioting and enjoying this episode of Happy Hour Econ. We will be here next week for a whole new episode. Talk to you then.
Listen & Watch
Share This Episode
Pull up a stool with Lou and Phil
Next
Round's
On Us
New Episodes, Straight to Your Inbox. No Cover Charge.
No spam, just good economics served with a side of laughs. Unsubscribe anytime.