31:56
Hold the Beef
Hosted by Lou Perez and Phillip W. Magness .
A Free To Choose Network production.
Show Notes
Plant-based burgers were supposed to take over the dinner table. Instead, they’re gathering frost in the freezer aisle while shoppers make a beeline for the brisket and sirloin. So what keeps fake meat on the shelves, and what would actually happen if we all gave up the real thing? Enjoy a tall glass of oat milk with Lou and Phil as they chew on diet trends, crop yields, and the curious case of conspicuous production on this week’s Happy Hour Econ.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and may contain errors.
Read Transcript
Speaker 1
Welcome back to Happy Hour Econ, where a comedian and an economist walk into a bar. I'm Lou Perez, the comedian. Economist. So vegans, they tend to be annoying. And I could tell you I know one vegan who isn't annoying. Just one. Out of all the vegans I have ever met, out of all the vegans in my life, there is one who is not annoying, but I don't think he's charismatic enough to get me to stop eating meat, but maybe there are some arguments that will change my eating habits and change your eating habits. If there are any vegans out there, well, we would know by now because you would have told us. But perhaps the economics of veganism will change us, change the world. First question, Phil, are you a vegan?
Speaker 2
I am not a vegan, and in fact, I'm pretty much the complete antithesis of a vegan. I'm also one of the few people, maybe there's many of th of us out there in the world who can accurately claim that veganism would kill me. And the reason being I have an extreme allergy to mushrooms and cashew nuts, which are two of the major components of the vegan diet. So, By nature, by all sorts of heredity, whatever it is that causes allergies, I guess I'm just destined to be a meat eater. Look.
Speaker 1
If you were an evil villain, you have just given the world the way to destroy you. That's it. Just cashews and mushrooms. That that's really interesting that that you say that because I think in a similar way that vegans have been, stereotypically annoying. I think there's also a batch of carnivores who are also annoying. And it's basically anybody who's just always shouting from the rafters, this is who I am, and this is what you should be, and we need to, we need to do this. But I think you bring up A really important point which is when it comes to food, when it comes to diet, everybody kinda responds differently. If you do have a have a a dangerous allergy, you're gonna have to stay away from a lot of stuff and a lot of stuff just just doesn't work for for people.
Speaker 2
Well, it's the ultimate expression of what economists refer to as subjective individual preference. you know, I have different tastes than you do, you have different tastes than your neighbor, your neighbor has different tastes from his neighbor. So it's and we express this in the way that we choose to consume things. the core issue of choice is that we all don't have to like the same deodorant or the same shampoo or the same meal for dinner. we have a variety of options that we've Pick from now some of those are more popular than others. for example, people like hamburgers. That seems to be a preference of the majority of the American population. So hamburgers are often in very high demand. You can get them almost everywhere. now, on the other hand, there are some very obscure niche dietary preferences that maybe are not nearly as abundant in the stores and the restaurants. And one of the interesting ones here is where does veganism fit on that spectrum?
Speaker 1
And when it comes to personal choices, I mean, we make choices for all sorts of reasons. Some of us, it's strictly lust, desire, taste. I want this hamburger. Then there are other people who are like, hey, I got my blood work back and I really should cut down on X, Y, or Z. If I'm gonna have a burger, it needs to be leaner. It needs to be less fat, more protein. And I think even when it comes to arguments about which diet is healthier, people know a lot more about what is in the food. and are making choices based on that rather than just like this overall, if you eat this, you're going to be healthier. Because anybody who has ever been the victim of a recall knows that just because it's lettuce doesn't necessarily mean that it's healthier. It might actually, you know, in the worst case scenario, put you in the put you in the hospital.
Speaker 2
The Great Taco Bell incident of a couple months ago. That's no, but but I think he hit on an important point here that you know, food consumption is a discovery process. we don't just wake up one morning and and decide, well, this type of steak tastes good for everybody, or this type of vegetable. We all have our own individual tastes and preferences. And part of that discovery process is you also learn things that don't agree with your stomach. And for some people that might be spicy foods. for me, you know, I I I learned in a very unfortunate way that mushrooms do not agree with me. they tend to come back up. and that's just not pleasant for anybody. I learned in another very unfortunate way, someone had put cashew milk in a coffee that I had ordered, and then I have an allergic reaction to it. And then it's well, my response to that is, well, I don't eat or drink cashew products anymore. so that's part of the discovery process. at the same time. I like steak and I like it seasoned a certain way. I like certain cuts of meat. I tend to like the the flank and strips portions of the cow and and their Latin American equivalents in particular. And you know, I'll I'll pick that over even a really high-end ultra tender filet just because I like that, but that's not going to be the same choice that everybody else makes. they're gonna find it through their own discovery.
Speaker 1
Yeah, there's something about the butcher's cut that just hits so right. something that I found too when you when I kind of changed up my diet and was eating, you know, quote unquote cleaner, it kind of made it difficult to go out to other restaurants because I had taken out so much of the stuff that I considered crap and they had the crap in. So then it was kind of like messing with my stomach. And something else that that I find is there is like sort of this big movement when it comes to like gut health. and you see, right now, if you guys are listening to this, when you go to Instagram, all these ads are just gonna pop up, about how important is your gut biome is and all that. And exactly
Speaker 2
Take your probiotics.
Speaker 1
and I almost and I almost feel like I'm somebody who's never had stomach troubles before. And I feel like, wait a minute, is this a case of this person has a messed up gut? And is therefore projecting onto everybody and saying, you know what, you can't eat bread because it's gonna mess with your gut biome and it's like, No dude, you can't eat bread because it's messing with your gut biome. I'm fine.
Speaker 2
I think there's quite a bit of that going around. And you get all these, fad diets have been a thing for as long as human history. and they come along with whether it's promising some extravagant health benefits if you only eat potatoes or if you only eat this certain type of meat or whatever it happens to be. And there's always gonna be an advocate out there so well. I started doing this weird sauerkraut diet. I think that's the one that RFK Jr. is pushing right now. And I only eat sauerkraut and suddenly it's made my life feel all wonderful and everything. that's not scientific evidence. It may be an expression of personal choice, and it may work for you. And if you want to go eat sauerkraut all day and all night, and that's the only thing you eat, great. you live with the consequences of that. You may s have smelly breath as well, and you may have other health indicators that that happen because of that. You're not getting the right kind of proteins or whatever it happens to be. But you know, that's your own choice and you get to pick the risks that come with that. but but there's always like this something in the human psyche that says we need to rationalize our choice in ways is not it's not enough to just say, I eat this 'cause I like it. It's I eat this because I have decided on this super fad diet with a pseudoscientific explanation that tells me it's good for me and therefore it's good for all of you too.
Speaker 1
years ago I met a couple who had made the transition to believe v just vegetarianism. And they were eating a lot of beans. And during that transition, they had they had to take this thing, I think it was called beano. And basically beano was a way for them to regulate their flatulence. And it's just so funny to see these, you know, a couple start to kind of look alike. They're both just rail thin and just the most amazing tutors. Out there. they you would think that if they farted they'd just pass out.
Speaker 2
There's negative externalities that come from bad diets.
Speaker 1
I think there was an underlying feel of superiority from them in a way, where it's sort where it's sort of like every bit of methane they released was just a they were showing they were just a little better than you.
Speaker 2
Well did d did it contribute to global warming.
Speaker 1
That that's right. They had to save penance for their for that. Yeah. when it comes to the economics, when it comes to your diet hitting your pocket, is a vegan diet cheaper if someone were to go that way?
Speaker 2
Well, it seems not to be because they're ultra specialized food items, you know, that have been processed in a certain way. And you know, it it's kind of interesting to me that veganism has this reputation of being more natural or more one with nature. And yet then you go eat or consume or see some of the processes to make things that are marketed as vegan products. And one of the really interesting things is that that they try to recreate meat. Yeah. using congealed chemical bound crushed up celery and mushroom and all these plant products, like held together with bonding agents. I mean, it's the most chemically intensive stuff that you can ever imagine. artificial coloring and flavors and it's like basically ingesting a chemical factory into your body, but the chemicals all happen to be plant-based, so therefore supposedly they're more natural. which it's just always kind of interesting to me on on how people rationalize that in their psyche. But I think there's an underlying economic concept behind it. And you know, I've done a little bit of work on this. My colleague, former colleague Pete Earle at American Institute for Economic Research. he and I worked together for several years, and he even went so far as to coin this the Magnus effect. we were talking about food economics one day. And and the basic idea here. Is that there's this well-known phenomenon in economic thinking. It goes back to a guy named Thorsten Veblen at the turn of the 20th century. He's a weird dude, but he had some occasional economic insights. And one of them was this theory called conspicuous consumption. And the idea behind it is why do people pay tens of thousands of dollars for a fancy Rolex watch that, you know, functionally it tells the same time as the $20 watch you can get at Walmart. or if you wanted a nice one, you could get a $1,000 watch at Costco that'll also sell tell you the time and it'll look gold and flashy and have some of the same aesthetics. Yet people want that Rolex brand. And the question is, why? Well, Vemplin says that this is a conspicuous act to signal to people around them that they're in the club, that they have elite tastes, that they have you know, refined. taste for certain types of products in a well-known luxury name brand. And we think about this, there's conspicuous consumption in all sorts of things. It's you buy a flashy car because you want your neighbor to see you driving the Corvette. some people will you know buy artwork that they hang in the house because they want people not because it's the the prettiest painting ever, but it's it's from a known artist and that signals refined tastes. you pay more For goods to get the brand or to dine at the elite restaurant or to have the fancy brand of champagne and be seen doing that because there's social value and status that comes out of it. so it's a really interesting way of looking at things. And he and Vlin says, this explains why people make certain types of economic decisions that are not strictly economizing on getting the best price. they're actually buying the brand in certain cases. So what I argue is that there's this an inverse to conspicuous consumption going on in the food industry on the producer side. And we can call that conspicuous production. And part of this comes into play with veganism and vegetarianism on a statistical level. So there are all these surveys of the US population where they ask people, what percentage of of you are are vegans? Want to take a guess?
Speaker 1
Hmm. would it be ten percent? Is that too high or too?
Speaker 2
Yeah, it's way too high. It's about one percent, maybe even less. But they all tell you. so they have an outsized every single one of them will announce the first thing after they meet you, I'm a vegan. And maybe it sounds like a big segment of the population, but you know, the survey data shows us it's roughly one percent of the population. And then if you expand that to vegetarians and some of the the broader categories, well that gets a little bit larger, but it's like four or five percent. since a very, very small percentage of the population is vegan. And yet you can find a vegan section of almost any menu at a fine dining restaurant. You can find a vegan section in every single grocery store. The question is why? I mean that this seems like a a lot of space on menus and store shelves are spent catering to a very, very tiny percentage of the population. And the argument I make is that this is an act of conspicuous production. Grocery stores want to be seen selling vegan stuff. Because it's associated in the minds of their customers with social responsibility or saving the environment or being natural or all these different things that have been cultivated around it, even though it's not really a money maker. same thing with menus and stuff like that. And the interesting thing is some of the economics of this, you start looking at the industry of the fake meat and all these burgers that are made out of congealed plant slurry with chemicals. And there was a huge explosion of these companies about three or four years ago. they all burst onto the scene and they had their IPOs on the stock market and everybody invested and then you had all these fa even fast food restaurants like we now sell plant burgers, big advertising campaigns everywhere, every grocery store shelf had it. Well, now look at the stocks of those companies today. A lot of them are teetering on the verge of bankruptcy. Others it's just selling for like pennies on the dollar. they're still producing, but they're nowhere near this sector that was supposed to take over the entire food industry and become a major menu staple. And I argue that that that comes from a misdiagnosis of the market. Everyone's thought, well, hey, this is the next big thing. We're gonna convert everybody to plants because it's natural and better for you and vegan, whatever. But everyone started tasting these things and they tasted terrible. And now nobody buys them. And yet they remain on the shelf because stores are betting that their customers want to see that and want to see other people buying it, meanwhile they're walking down to the bacon aisle.
Speaker 1
Yeah, let's take a moment to remember the impossible burger. That impossible abomination. Because it was all over the place and then it wasn't. you could still you could still see it there, you know, it's sort of like a a ghost kind of haunting. I know plants don't have souls, but it it's c it kinda has that
Speaker 2
Your plants don't talk to you and tell you that, don't eat me, don't eat me.
Speaker 1
And it's something where, you know, just looking at sort of trends in a world kind of like the past I would say ten years or so, where something like protein is so front of mind for so many people, and protein is healthy and you need protein, especially as you get older, you want you want protein. I remember seeing debates between like vegans and omnivores or you know, c carnivores talking about, you know, can get the same amount of protein like in a in a peanut butter sandwich as you can in a whatever cut of beef. And the thing that they leave out all the time is, well, yeah, I mean technically you could get the same amount of protein, but what comes with that are a lot of calories. And when one of the biggest health indicators is obesity, you have people who want to be consuming fewer calories and getting more protein. So just something like If you like a a lean cut of beef and you want fifty grams of protein, that'll cost you three hundred and forty calories, which is really good.
Speaker 2
Yeah.
Speaker 1
But yeah, but then with peanut butter, if you want fifty grams of protein, you're gonna be over thirteen hundred calories. And think about if people were, you know, sticking to the two thousand calories a day, my goodness, that's that's a lot. That's a lot, lot, lot of calories to be spent on a peanut butter sandwich. So I think People are definitely making these choices from a position of knowing what they want and knowing what they what they need.
Speaker 2
Well, i i in some ways it's it's almost like an ideology. It's they that people select something for perfectly valid reasons. sometimes that reason may seem kooky to you and I or to somebody else, but I'm not gonna deny them their choice to go eat vegan food or go do the sauerkraut diet or the all steak diet or whatever it happens to be. But it comes with consequences associated with it. one of one of the more interesting things I noticed about this, and this is kinda how I I I stumbled into this conspicuous production idea, is whenever there's a hurricane or a natural disaster coming and it's on the news, especially if you live in Florida or on the Gulf Coast or something like that, what do people do? They run on the grocery stores and they just raid the shelves and it's everything is is taken. And I was watching the news one day and it was like there's a hurricane barreling down on Florida and and they're there in the the store and they're showing all these empty, cleared out shelves in the meat section, except for one section of freezer, and you zoom in and it's the vegan fake meat plant alternative section of that freezer, and it looks like a normal Tuesday. Nothing's been touched. people are conspicuously avoiding that section of the free freezer, even though there's this hurricane coming. And it's that's kind of interesting. And then the very beginning of COVID in 2020, you know, the same phenomenon happened nationwide. I don't know why people thought, well, we're shutting everything down, therefore the stores are also going to shut down, and there's the giant run on toilet paper. But there's also a giant run on groceries. And you could go into the local Target or Walmart or Safeway. And I did. And the burgers are all gone. The chicken tenders are gone. The the bacon, the usual meat stuff. And then you get to that little that one aisle that's the plant section. And there's the compressed veggie tofu cashew steak of whatever it happens to be that's been sitting there since probably the store first stocked it in 2016. And growing dust on it. and here's another evidence of the the chemicals. The stuff has a Ridiculously long shelf lives. I guess there's so much preservative and bonding agents and stuff and to hold the fake burger together that you can stick it in a a freezer and it'll sit there for years on end. It's like the the old doomsday bunkers from the Cold War, where they occasionally stumble on one and there's like a package of dried crackers from 1956, and it still tastes the same awfulness as it did when they packaged it. But It it's an expression of consumer choice. People bypass these things and send a market signal when they do so. And yet stores want people to see that they're selling them nonetheless. So it's almost like a giant advertising billboard for the store that says, We are socially responsible, we care about the environment and nature and natural stuff, even though people don't buy this. So we're gonna keep it on the shelves anyway.
Speaker 1
I'm just imagining all of our prepper fans out there. You know, the end of the world comes, you guys all survive, and you come up out of your bunkers, and the only food remaining that you're able to eat, some mad scientist assembled slop. And it's not even it's not even soy and green, you because at least soil and green is, you know, made from it's made from people, but people are meat.
Speaker 2
It i it's soil it cashew and soil it mushroom.
Speaker 1
So when we're comparing, you know, the economic cost of say like animal agriculture versus plant agriculture, how do how do they match up as far as you know like the environmental impact? Because one of things with plants is, you know, need arable land, you need fertilizer as well. and a lot of people who happen to be in in the vegan camp are very much in support of quote unquote organic. Yeah. very anti, you know, kinda fertilizer. And accepting that on like a global scale, if you didn't want fertilizer, well, there's gonna be a lot of a lot of dead, because you just won't be able to grow as much food. Yeah.
Speaker 2
As fertilizer, it applies also to some of these genetically modified crops that have increased their yield. it's also the resistance to bugs and blight and disease and fungus. you know, nature is a pretty brutal place out there. And there are certain parts of the world where you know, if there's a heavy rain sea system that comes through and it floods your field, next thing your field that was going to produce. A bunch of wheat or corn or something for next year is now covered in mold. And it's unusual. And th this is historically, you go back to the Middle Ages and really until about the late nineteenth century, famines are extremely common in human history. And not just like famines where the crop goes bad for one season, it's famines where this disease, the potato blight, hits Ireland, and for multiple years on end, the entire crop fails. And people starve. This is a recurring theme of human history. But what we've done is we've used technology to address this in multiple ways. It's breeding and cross-breeding strains of certain food items to make them more disease resistant. the GMOs that people say they hate because they're they're scared of you know genetic modification that sounds like mad scientist stuff. And you know, I'm within reason, I think we should pay attention to these concerns. science should advance for no on very sound ethical principles. But at the same time, just because something is GMO rejecting it means that you're probably putting people at risk or harm for starving because you're reducing crop yields. Fertilizer, the same thing. what does it do? It turns previously unusable or low-yield land into very high yield land that has crops in abundance. You you Grow crops in abundance, well, what's the other effect? It reduces the price on it. So you don't get starvation and hunger through poverty as much anymore. and then there's the whole meat question of that. We use a we've converted a lot of land that was previously just the wild, the wilderness, into grazing territory for cows and sheep and chicken and all the different things that we eat because they're delicious. And well, what does that do? It turns previously low productivity land into wildly productive use and gives people something that they seem to like. You know, the the vast majority of Americans eat meat because they like it. It doesn't mean that they're bad people or they're unethical. it means that, you know, that's an expression of their taste. And one of the things I always point out to this these movements that claim, hey, we can convert everybody to veganism or To sauerkraut or to whatever their their fad diet of the moment happens to be, it's actually the the diversity of food options that makes the whole system work. We should have lots of crops and a variety of crops. We should have lots of animals and a variety of animals and and meat to draw from because that's going to satisfy the broadest array of the dietary preferences of the world and do so very cheaply. If you take one of those out of the equation, Well, you I it it actually would be really bad for the cows and pigs and chickens if we banned meat. because we're at such a state where there are more cows grazing today than would exist otherwise naturally. precisely because we've created an economy around all the products, be that milk and cheese and steak and leather and everything that's used, every part of the cow is used economically. And that comes about precisely because there are Consumers that want this stuff.
Speaker 1
Yeah, and also I think you bring up a really good point. All of these animals serve a purpose. And when that purpose is taken away, bye bye animals. Yes. Just think about like India. And India, you know, they revere their cows, so that's why cows are causing traffic and that sort of thing. But we're not India. So in a world where, you know, you're no longer able to milk or to slaughter, you know, cows, well Yeah, yeah, yeah. Turn them loose.
Speaker 2
We turn them loose. Then you have cows wandering through suburbia, eating and munching on your garden.
Speaker 1
In the section of the country where I live, we have a lot of deer. We have a very high, deer population. And it's either hunters cull the population or the deer starve to death in the winter. And it's a car
Speaker 2
To your car.
Speaker 1
or run into my car or or or keep pooping on my front lawn. I I'm starting to think it's it they have something personal against me that they that they choose to do it in front of my lawn and they're always making eye contact when they're when they're doing it.
Speaker 2
Your launch the porta potty for the the local deer herd.
Speaker 1
Yeah, exactly. The new the New Jersey deer herd. They all know me. They don't like me. They want me to move out. And and also, it's something that that I had just learned recently is not every piece of land, at least in the United States, is made for farming. there there's land that is just that's just suitable for grazing. And what happens to that land when that when it's no longer grazed?
Speaker 2
Well it's taken out of production. You're reducing the possibility of uses for it. you are turning it into something that would now sit idle because the bec best economic use for it is no longer available.
Speaker 1
We should probably talk about subsidies and what role subsidies play on both sides, both on the the meat side, the plant side, and what would a food economy look like w without them?
Speaker 2
So basically, since the New Deal era, the agriculture sector of the United States, and this is everything in it, from meat and cows and chickens and sort of stuff like that, to the grain you can grow, the corn, the wheat, the rice, all the different crops you can grow, is heavily regulated and subsidized by the government. Why? Because FDR said to relieve us of the depression, we're going to come in with this giant price sustaining scheme of agriculture subsidies to make the farmers happy. And actually what it ends up doing is it distorts the price signal throughout the market nationwide, enabled by a Supreme Court decision, Wickard versus Philburn, that said that, you know, even if you produce your own crops for your own consumption, you are distorting the market and therefore interstate commerce and therefore Congress can regulate it all. so that all happened in the New Deal era. The second effect of it, after they established this power, is it created very small, narrow but politically concentrated constituencies. Of all the different farm and agriculture groups. So that's a tiny percent of the population works in this sector, but the soybean farmers are a huge lobby. The corn farmers are a huge lobby. The cattle farmers are a huge lobby. And what do they do? Well, if they're getting subsidies from the federal government, they're going to Washington every time anyone proposes ending those subsidies and saying, Well, let me remind you, I'm from Iowa and Iowa's the first primary in the presidential cycle. when they have their caucuses. If you take away our subsidies, we're gonna remember that next time you're running for president. Yeah. And we're gonna vote against you. So there's all sorts of incentives that come about from being a b beneficiary of agricultural subsidies. you know, so and vegans will point this out, but so will the meat eaters. They'll say, well, the vegans will say, well, big meat is subsidized. And I'll say, yes, it is. But so is Sugarcane, so are soybeans, so are corn, so are probably mushrooms, all these different things that that they prefer to eat are heavily subsidized because we have a essentially it's an unfree sector in agriculture that's persisted since the New Deal era to the present.
Speaker 1
And in recent memory, there have been a number of bills that have been passed in some states to make it illegal to develop or sell lab grown meat. Yes. and it it seems like that controversy is kind of I don't know, kind of gone away. I mean maybe people aren't as into the idea of lab grown meat as I thought they would be, but you know, where where are you on that, Phil? Don't you want to grow your own meat and
Speaker 2
Again, it's I think it's Magnus effects, it's conspicuous production. all of these weird, fad, lab grown, or you know, there were also some states that passed laws that say, well, if you make your weird congled plant slurry burger, you can't call it a hamburger, because it doesn't really have meat in it, or you can't call it a steak, or you can't call mashed up cashews and almonds milk because it's not really milk. It's a substitute product. And there are all these laws that say the this sort of thing. And from a personal choice perspective, I look at that as like, okay, this is silly. If you're accidentally buying almond milk and not realizing that it's almond milk, you know, that that's error is on you as the consumer. So it's a superfluous law that I think was being pushed for cheap political talking points in all of these different industries and sectors. But then at the same time, they were always targeting something that's a very niche consumption product, lab grown meat for the.0002% of the population that wakes up in the morning and says, You know what I want today? A lab grown steak. That that okay, it's going to affect their choice and restrict it. But the general public is looking at that and they're like, I want there to be lab-grown meat out there for other people to eat. And I want to look at it, but that's weird. I don't want to eat it myself. that seems to be the current consumer attitude. Maybe that'll change in time, I don't know. But again, I think it's a lot of virtue signaling and other types of signaling, both in the production of this stuff and then in the politicians that are taking stances to try to ban it.
Speaker 1
Well, whatever you're planning on eating today, we want to thank you for enjoying a meal of Happy Hour Econ. We are grass finished, we are organic, and we have too many weird chemicals to list. We'll see you next week for an all new episode of Happy Hour Econ.
Listen & Watch
Share This Episode
Pull up a stool with Lou and Phil
Next
Round's
On Us
New Episodes, Straight to Your Inbox. No Cover Charge.
No spam, just good economics served with a side of laughs. Unsubscribe anytime.