Back to Episodes
Artwork for American Heavy Metal

23:23

American Heavy Metal

Hosted by Lou Perez and Phillip W. Magness .

A Free To Choose Network production.

Show Notes

Steel is back, baby! At least, that’s the pitch, now that a company plans to build the largest steel mill in U.S. history (in the fields of Iowa) and politicians are already taking a victory lap four years before a single beam rolls off the line. But is this a real industrial comeback, or the latest chapter in a protectionist saga that started before the ink on the Constitution was dry? Lou and Phil find out whether Big Steel’s big promises have any mettle at all on this week’s Happy Hour Econ.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and may contain errors.

Read Transcript

Speaker 1

Welcome back to Happy Hour Econ, where a comedian and an economist walk into a bar. I'm Lou Perez, the comedian.

Speaker 2

Phil Magnus, the economist.

Speaker 1

In the United States, steel is back, baby! Around the year 2030, that's when it's gonna be. There's a company, Masabi Metallics, which sounds like a Metallica tribute band. Masabi Metallics is planning to build the largest steel mill in US history, and they're doing it in Iowa. So, I guess every everybody's celebrating. Who doesn't like steel?

Speaker 2

Yeah, yeah. I'm not a huge fan of the steel industry.

Speaker 1

No.

Speaker 2

no, it's popular for politicians to say that they are, because people make steel. this is a crucial thing to build stuff. And it is. But the steel industry is a very large international market. And the interesting thing in the United States, although we do produce steel here, I mean it's not like it ever went away. We actually consume more steel than we can produce at a market rate internally to our own borders. So what this means is that we've historically imported steel. And the narrative you hear on the political scene all says, well, hey, it comes from China because China ramped up their steel production over the past 30 years. the reality is most imported steel in the US, in excess of what we produce, actually before the Trump era, before all these tariffs came place, came from places like Canada, came from Brazil, came from people we would consider friendly trading partners. And in a given year, China was always like tenth or twelfth or fifteenth on that list. It wasn't the number to steel producer or anything like that. in fact it it it falls typically somewhere a little beneath the Netherlands and the total volume of steel imported into the United States. so there's a lot of misconceptions just already off the bat about where steel is and where it's gone. And yet it occupies this historical presence because you know, people associate it with big industry. they envision the old steel mills of you know like the early twentieth century and Andrew Carnegie, the US Steel Corporation and just putting out these giant beams and bars and plates of steel that go into ships and buildings and you name it.

Speaker 1

I had no idea that the Netherlands made steel. They do indeed. I just imagined them, you know, since they have wooden shoes, I just imagined everything just be just being

Speaker 2

And in windmills. Yeah, yeah, exactly. They actually have a a very large shipping industry and I think quite a bit of it comes out of that sector. But yeah. steel is actually made all over the world because it's it's such a useful resource is in in anything and everything. You know, to pretend that we can only make steel in one place is just it kind of defies economic sense. I says diversified necessarily.

Speaker 1

And you brought up a little bit of the the history of US steel. You know, when was steel up? When was it down? When I think of steel, I think of like movies from like the nineteen seventies and I think of like the deer hunter, right? Scenes like that. And with steel mills, they often have this mystique about kind of dying towns, you know, the the end of an era in the United States, that that sort of thing.

Speaker 2

It's mystique and it is tied to a very particular notion of what a steel mill is. And people get that in their head. They think this gigantic factory, where there's a truck that's like unloading ore that it's been dug out of the mountain into one end of the factory, and then it goes onto the floor and there's smelting and there's liquid metal pouring everywhere and is dumping into molds. And then on the other end of this gigantic factory, there's like a train car that's loading up all the steel beams and stuff, or or or pressed plates of everything. This is what we call historically is referred to as an integrated steel mill, a start to finish materials out of the ground to finish product. and that's the whole process. this is actually an older antiquated way of producing steel. I mean it it still has its industrial uses, but it's also very dirty. It's you know it's an all hands on deck type of a gigantic factory and then Historically, you know, an entire town would be built around one of these things. More recently, the more modern versions of steel production, you have what are referred to as mini mills. And these are you know, smaller units that do one step of that. Sometimes they'll take scrap metal and just smelt it down and process it and clean it up and and you get a new steel beam out the other end. So it's like dividing all the the different segments of production. A mini mill is nowhere near as large as an integrated firm. And they're actually much more versatile economically because you know if the steel mill or the steel sector say becomes very hot right now, there's a high demand for steel, it's easier to put a new mini mill into production. It's easier to build it. It's also easier to activate an old mill that's been offline because they're they're they're they're versatile on it, says. Contrast that with this thing that Trump is trying to build in Iowa, which sounds like, although I, you know, I think the descriptions are very vague, but it sounds like a giant integrated firm, the largest one ever built, won't be done for another four and a half years. This sounds like a giant integrated mill where you have huge capital expenditures up front to get these giant smelting machines in i in action. and then if the steel market tanks or there's a drop off in demand for steel, what what are your options? You just shut that down. there's no versatility, there's no responsiveness to the market. So I hear something like Iowa, I'm like, this is actually a reflection of government distorting the market and steering steel production to an older, less efficient way of doing things simply because people have this nostalgic vision in their heads for a giant factory belching out smoke and putting out steel beams.

Speaker 1

Yeah, as you describe it, basically what's in my head are a a bunch of guys with soot all over their faces. And then the end of Terminator Two, sorry for the spoiler alert. When both you know, cyborgs melt into the

Speaker 2

Like the giant vat that's coming overhead with chains.

Speaker 1

Yeah, just l it looks like lava for for no re I've no idea what they're making. It doesn't make it you know. We talk about, you know, some the advancements of technology, like is steel even the go to anymore compared to you know, other building materials. Right, right.

Speaker 2

It it it really is not. but one of the things here is so the United States we're a large geographically diverse country, and one of the results of that is that we have a lot of iron ore deposits scattered around and mountainous regions around the country, which is great. It's a resource. use it economically. There are things you can do with that, but it's also meant that it creates a political constituency around having this industry that historically was seen as you know, crucial. yeah, steel's a big part of industrial production of making things. But you can go back to the founding of the country and I researched this. The very first Congress in 1789. We've got a new constitutional system. One of the first bills they have, James Madison writes it's to set the tariff rate. And he goes up in front of Congress and basically hands him a piece of paper and the bill says The tariff of the United States shall be blank and asks them to figure it in. And they're like debating should it be 3% or 5% or 2%? And then there's this guy from Pennsylvania by the name of Thomas Fitzsimmons who stands up and says, I'd like to offer an amendment to Mr. Madison's bill. And the amendment is basically well, we have this infant iron industry in Pennsylvania, and it's facing competition from the Brits abroad who we just want our independence from. we should tax them at a higher rate and give ourselves a Lego. And that's the start of protectionism in the United States. Pitts Simmons challenging Madison. And Madison's actually writing letters to his wife, Dolly, saying, Yeah, the stupid tariff bill. I thought it was going to be a like a quick debate of a day or two, and it's been dragging on for a month because these Pennsylvanians want protectionism for their iron industry. Well, that iron industry is the predecessor to the steel industry, which is just much it's a more refined version of iron. And, you know, I I refer to the sector, it's the infant industry. It's the baby that never grew up. Because here we are 250 years later, we're still protecting the same damn thing.

Speaker 1

really amazed y you go back at the start and it's just like being where we are today. Exactly still doing the same stuff, still making the same mistakes. We're talking about one mil in Iowa four years from now. You know, does that really mean the industry is back? You know, are we really back, baby?

Speaker 2

It it means that the government has once again, for the hundredth time in our our two hundred and fifty-year existence, come in and distorted the market signals on steel production in such a way that has steered corporate decisions into partnerships with the federal government to adopt an older, less efficient, less maneuverable. More cumbersome version of steel production that actually looks like an old factory from the early twentieth century.

Speaker 1

We often talk about the scene and the unseen. What impact is this going to have on the economy? Are are we able to see the unseen before we've even seen the scene?

Speaker 2

the scene is that we've used tariff protectionism to bolster a domestic industry and a certain type of steel production. And it seems to be there's also subsidies to attract that certain type of steel production. So we're spending money on it from the public sector and we're taxing the private sector to steer economic production around this certain type of steel production. Well, the unseen is the economic activity that does not take place precisely because resources have been steered into that. And you think about it, well, steel is in almost everything industrially. you have a very concentrated benefit that goes to that owner of the steel factory that's being built in Iowa, and maybe a couple other steel factories that already exist that now are seeing their production boosted by artificial higher prices from the tariffs. they're they're protected from competition from abroad. so they're they're making bank. They're thinking, all right, yeah, the tariff is working for me. maybe I can afford now to increase my employee base by a hundred people. And then Trump will show up or some other politician will show up and say, we added a hundred jobs to the economy. But what's the unseen here? Well now steel is more expensive and steel goes into automobile manufacturing. And suddenly there's an automobile plant in Tennessee that its raw material costs more because of the tariff to employ those hundred people, but maybe that automobile plant employs a thousand people. And because it's suddenly now less economical to produce at the previous level that they were operating at, they lay those people off temporarily. So you get a larger number of people potentially that are out of jobs and you don't see it because it's not recorded there, precisely because the raw material of steel is now more expensive. And this is just like a one anecdote. But you see this type of thing playing out across the economy. And we know from our best economic models or mathematical constructions of how Trade basically works that the damages on net, the unseen, are larger than the benefits that are seen to that one narrow sector. You just have very concentrated benefits for, you know, a couple hundred people at this one factory and a couple hundred people at another factory. And yet the dispersed costs fall on 340 million people ultimately, because we all have to pay a little bit more for a toaster oven for a refrigerator for a car. And then also there's some concentrated dispersed costs in certain larger sectors that now have much more expensive raw materials, and that changes their production decisions, and that means that they scale back on what they're able to produce for the year and therefore people lose jobs.

Speaker 1

And with the the building of this coming, you know, four years from now, I would imagine say you are somebody who does work in the steel industry, you're probably working somewhere else already. Yeah. Or if you're somebody who doesn't have those skills yet, it's quite an investment to invest what I I don't know how long it takes to, you know, kind of get up to speed on, you know, technology and and the roles that you would need in a steel mill, but it seems like there's quite a personal investment in there and who knows if that's necessarily going to pan out. Again, it's in Iowa. I don't know if if that's gonna be a the magnet

Speaker 2

Yeah, yeah. And this is the other thing. It's like this is the fallacy of the central planner, the government coming in and saying, Well, this is the sector we need to create jobs in. And that's effectively what they're doing when they're saying we want more steel mills. It's like, Well, new jobs should be created, but they should be in this one sector because we've determined that it's good to have a giant smoke bilching factory. Well, there's survey data out there that's been run multiple times over the past decade or so where they ask the American public, like, What kind of career do you want? And then they juxtapose that to another question. It's like, should we have more employment in the manufacturing sector or the steel sector? Things like that. So you ask these two questions. And almost everybody says, yes, I want more steel manufacturing. But then when you ask them Do you want that job yourself? Will you abandon whatever you're doing, whether it's working at the local Walmart or being a teacher or being in the service industry or being a corporate executive, you name it. They said, No, I somebody else should do that job, not me. I wouldn't give up my job to go work in a steel mill, but we should have steel mills. So there's a disconnect going on here. People, I think they they almost fetishize this conception of the past built around the nostalgia of the steel mill. But they can never envision themselves being the ones working it. That's for somebody else. And you see this in the actual economic data. So every quarter, so the the US government does a bunch of employment surveys, the Bureau of Labor Statistics. And one of the questions they ask from industrial manufacturers, they also ask in the farm sector, is like, How many job openings do you currently have that are unfilled? And it's you know, get an indicator. It's like, is this sector saturated? There are I mean, is it like College professors where there's a hundred job seekers for one position? Or is it something where, you know, they're having trouble filling the jobs? Well, guess what the manufacturing sector looks like every time they ask this survey? It has an abundance of unfilled jobs. there are more open manufacturing jobs unfilled today than there were 25 years ago, in the supposed era where our hollowed-out industrial base occurred. so that's a complete myth, this notion that you know we've lost our sector. There are firms still willing to hire here. They just have unfilled jobs. And the notion that, hey, the government needs to come in and create even more of those unfilled jobs that everyone for nostalgic reasons envisions their neighbor working in but not themselves. you know, this is the a peak of insanity for.

Speaker 1

we could easily just shoot to an episode of Mike Rose podcast and he could just start talking about this because that's something he's talked about for a really long time. He's saying the job openings are there. It's just people aren't either they don't have the skills in the trades or they don't want to do it.

Speaker 2

want to do and they don't want to gain the skills. Yes. Yeah. because you know that that's and fine. If that it doesn't interest you to operate a giant smelting machine. You know, I understand why. That's you don't want to be one of those soot-covered factory workers in the in the old movies that everyone envisions.

Speaker 1

Although I am thinking about your favorite guy with a a master's in puppetry. If we could get him and his marionette down at the mill and see what kind of show they could put on it. You know, there'd be nothing like I mean the marionette will quickly go on fire, but

Speaker 2

The th the Terminator scene, done with puppets. Yes.

Speaker 1

I'm going to green light that. I'm taking out a mortgage on my house to do that. you know, a question that I had, and I think y you've you've sort of hit on it, sort of like wondering why now? You know, why is this happening? And according to Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, he said, quote, These are your two hundred and thirty two tariffs, the steel tariffs at work. Without those tariffs, this mine doesn't get built and this steel plant does not get built. I just wonder W what else? You know, what else are the tariffs building? What are the tariffs responsible for or

Speaker 2

this is Lutnik, or as I sometimes call him tariff Fauci. He he is wetted to an idea that like tariffs are this tool that you can direct the economy with towards strategic things and steals, one of them that he's settled on. He has a whole other list of others. And you can see him on the Sunday morning TV shows. He goes on there and he just rattles out all these things that are supposedly being done as a result of all these tariffs that have been put put in place. what he's reading out the successes of, alleged successes of, so I'm using quotation marks around this are the results of the political distortions his tariffs and Trump's tariffs and federal government tariffs have created. they have redirected resources to sectors that he thinks should be winners. The unseen are or the losers are things that never get built because steel is more expensive. Aluminum's more expensive, you know, computer chips are more expensive. You run down the entire list of anything and everything that's been protected with Tariffs, it means something else is more expensive somewhere. Or it means consumers now have to devote a larger share of their budget to purchasing something at a higher price. And there's a really interesting study that came out about this from the New York Federal Reserve last week. And what they did is a group of Fed economists, they looked at price trends on a narrow but important slice of consumer goods. So the things that are most likely to be affected by tariffs. And they they looked at the trends from, you know, you have the inflation. Problem in 2022, 23 under the Biden administration when it just soared. And yeah, bad. inflation is bad. prices went way up on all these goods, but they had noticed after they finally turned the corner in the inflation problem, there had been a downward trajectory that had been playing out since about mid-2024 through January, February, March of 2025 is kind of when it returned finally back down to some. sensible level, and it had actually dipped even a little bit into the negative. In other words, prices were no longer inflating. They were coming down below their some of their previous level on certain goods. And this Fed study notes that that's the exact moment these tariffs Lutnik is championing went into place. And it projects a counterfactual it says Well, what if we didn't have the tariffs and that trend continued across the rest of 2025 and 2026? And they come up with the conclusion that, you know, prices not only would have stabilized, they would have gone down a little bit back from where they had been in 2024. Again, this whole thing affordability being the crisis right now that every poll and every voter is telling you, well, that was the answer to let that trend continue. But instead, we disrupted it by putting tariffs on everything, and it's really felt on consumer goods. And there's all sorts of estimates of, you know, what's the the actual amount? and I think this one study it estimated about almost three percentage points in price increases were attributable to the effects of tariffs. And that's spread across every consumer in America. So there are very real economic losses and harms that have come from these policies. It's just they're harms that are unseen because it means I don't get to buy the thing I wanted to buy because my grocery bill and my Walmart bill this month was a little bit more than it would have been, all to pay for the tariff.

Speaker 1

Right. And also what happens if a new administration comes in and cuts or waives the tariffs? Now suddenly there's more volatility and then you have breaking ground on this new

Speaker 2

Steel mill. Yeah. Well, that's the classic problem because these are huge capital-intensive factories where you know, like a a giant smelter unit, the you know, that the the VAT from Terminator to install this. This is like a multi-million dollar piece of machinery. you can't just order that overnight and then install it, and then the steel market collapses or declines, and then suddenly you sell off your asset. You're gonna take a loss on that. These are things that take months, if not years, to install. They're huge capital intensive goods and money is tied up in getting that machinery in place. Well, the fact that they built this gigantic integrated mill, the largest steel mill in history, now means that they have a Hulk that cannot adapt very rapidly to changing economic conditions, such as the repeal of the tariffs that were put in place to create it.

Speaker 1

And I think the most important question is, with this new mill in Iowa, does that mean the Pittsburgh Steelers have to move to Iowa? Yeah. They're LARPing as Steelers, right?

Speaker 2

Well it is. I mean we're gonna get the football version of the field of dreams or something in there in the cornfield out there. you got a New Steel or stadium next to the the New Steel mill. Well and pit Pittsburgh's an interesting case because you know that's that's steel country. that's where this you know, this Thomas Fitzsimmons guy who was a Pennsylvania steel or iron industry at the t at the founding era. But Pittsburgh as a city did kind of go into that rust belt phase and then they started to diversify. they started to move into other economic sectors. And I don't know if anyone's been to downtown Pittsburgh recently. It's a lot different than it was twenty years ago.

Speaker 1

I was there once a few years ago. It's really nice.

Speaker 2

Yeah. So you got beautiful li rivers converging and

Speaker 1

Yeah, I got a ride with with an Uber driver and he was legitimately so happy to show me his city. Yeah. He there was like such pride there. There was a some fantastic cafes. I had a I had an amazing latte when I was there. And I'm like, I'm having a latte in steel country. Yes.

Speaker 2

Like people want to go there. Yeah. and I don't blame them. that and that, you know, there's back to the thing. This this old dirty giant factory steel mill town from the turn of the century, I I don't think you want to be vacationing there. Yeah, someone could conceivably vacation today in Pittsburgh or one of these cities that has diversified its economy and rebound it. So again, I think a lot of this is just at the end of the day, it's driven by nostalgia for a past that really didn't exist and wasn't nearly as great as we now make it out to be. I don't know.

Speaker 1

I'm a weird guy. I might want a vacation in a place like that with smokestacks and soot and visit my my terminator, my little terminator. Burning up. We hope you enjoy this episode of Happy Hour Econ. Come back next week for an all-new episode. See you then.

Share This Episode

Pull up a stool with Lou and Phil

Next
Round's
On Us

New Episodes, Straight to Your Inbox. No Cover Charge.

Sign up to get a quick note each week when a new round (episode) is ready to pour.

No spam, just good economics served with a side of laughs. Unsubscribe anytime.

Happy Hour Econ

Now Playing

American Heavy Metal